India is reportedly considering forcing smartphone manufacturers to preinstall a state-run app that enables always-on satellite-based location tracking, raising significant concerns over user privacy and freedom. The proposal would require smartphones to be equipped with this feature at all times, meaning users can't switch it off or even opt out of it.
The move has been met with strong opposition from major tech giants like Apple, Google, and Samsung, who have expressed their disapproval in a confidential letter to the Indian government. The India Cellular & Electronics Association (ICEA), which represents these companies, describes the proposal as "regulatory overreach" that could compromise sensitive information of military personnel, judges, corporate executives, journalists, and ordinary citizens.
Critics argue that such a move would be an overreach of the government's authority and potentially undermine personal freedoms. The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) has sounded the alarm on this proposal, stating that it would allow phone companies and law enforcement to access users' exact locations at any time, without legal due process.
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi's administration has cited concerns about law enforcement agencies struggling to obtain precise location data during investigations, citing cell tower data as an unreliable tool. The Indian government claims the proposed feature is designed to help keep citizens safe from crime and ensure that law enforcement agencies have a more accurate way of tracking suspects.
However, critics see this proposal as an Orwellian move aimed at expanding the state's surveillance capabilities, even if it means sacrificing individual privacy and freedoms in the process.
The move has been met with strong opposition from major tech giants like Apple, Google, and Samsung, who have expressed their disapproval in a confidential letter to the Indian government. The India Cellular & Electronics Association (ICEA), which represents these companies, describes the proposal as "regulatory overreach" that could compromise sensitive information of military personnel, judges, corporate executives, journalists, and ordinary citizens.
Critics argue that such a move would be an overreach of the government's authority and potentially undermine personal freedoms. The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) has sounded the alarm on this proposal, stating that it would allow phone companies and law enforcement to access users' exact locations at any time, without legal due process.
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi's administration has cited concerns about law enforcement agencies struggling to obtain precise location data during investigations, citing cell tower data as an unreliable tool. The Indian government claims the proposed feature is designed to help keep citizens safe from crime and ensure that law enforcement agencies have a more accurate way of tracking suspects.
However, critics see this proposal as an Orwellian move aimed at expanding the state's surveillance capabilities, even if it means sacrificing individual privacy and freedoms in the process.
i mean who doesn't want their every move tracked all the time? it's not like we have enough to worry about already with social media and google tracking our every click... but no, because one tiny thing isn't enough for the powers that be 
, like, we're living in 2025 already, can't they just leave us alone? But on the other hand, I mean, safety first, right? The idea that law enforcement agencies are struggling to get precise location data is valid, and I'm not saying that's necessarily a bad thing. But forcing phone manufacturers to preinstall this app? That's like, taking it too far 
.
. I mean, have you seen all the movies about dystopian futures? This sounds like something out of Blade Runner 
. But on the other hand, what if it's really necessary for safety reasons? Like, what if there's a real emergency and the government needs to track someone down ASAP? 
they wanna track us everywhere all the time? like what's next? forcing us to wear smart glasses that monitor our every move? 
i mean, whats wrong with a lil bit of privacy? do we need the gov to know where we are at all times? it just sounds so creepy. and whats with apple google samsung bailing out on this one? shouldnt they be like "nope not gonna happen" instead of just saying "sorry india"? 
I mean what's next? The government wanting you to track your own life 24/7? It's like they think we're all just a bunch of sheep waiting to be herded. Newsflash: we don't need some fancy app telling us where we are at all times. It's a total invasion of our personal space. And what's the real reason behind this? Is it really about keeping citizens safe, or is it just an excuse for them to expand their surveillance reach? I mean come on, who needs always-on location tracking anyway? It's like they're trying to turn us all into some kind of modern-day Big Brother characters 
Like, can't we just enjoy our data without Big Brother always watching? 
I mean, who needs that much location info anyway? 'Hey, I'm at a coffee shop with my laptop and cat... oh wait, my phone is tracking me too' 
. This feels like something out of a sci-fi movie! 
Can we just opt-out already? 
"
Forcing a state-run app to be preinstalled is like, totally invading our privacy 
And seriously, who needs always-on location tracking? Like, I'm not doing anything bad, and I don't want some govt agency breathing down my neck just 'cause I'm walking down the street 
. It's time for them to focus on the real issues, like corruption and poverty instead of playing around with our personal freedoms 
.
. I mean, who wants the government tracking their every move 24/7? It feels like a total overreach of authority 
. This is exactly the kind of thing that should make us question the government's intentions, not just their methods 
.
. We shouldn't be willing to sacrifice our digital rights for the sake of convenience or security 
Making us install an always-on tracking feature on our phones is just too much. I mean, think about it, even if you were doing nothing wrong, you'd be tracked 24/7 just because of where you are. It's like living in a sci-fi movie, but not the cool kind. 
The big tech companies are right to speak out against this. Who gets to decide what's good for us, anyway? 
. It's not just about keeping citizens safe from crime, it's about the government getting a stranglehold on our personal lives 
. I mean, think about it, we're talking about always-on satellite-based location tracking here - what's to stop them from using that info to monitor our every move? 
And who's going to regulate this? The Indian government, with its own agenda in mind 
. And what about the tech giants speaking out against it? That just means they're trying to silence the truth and cover their own tracks 
. We need to wake up, people! 
And what about people who don't want this feature? Do they have a right to opt out? I hope the government is thinking that one through... 
can u imagine bein tracked all the time no matter where u go or what u do? its like something outta a sci-fi movie 
india wants to make ur phone always-on trackin' feature mandatory which is straight up creepy 
and u cant opt out or even switch it off...i guess modis admin thinks its 4 law enforcement & safety but really its more like they wanna spy on everyone 
It's like, we already give up a lot of our personal info when we sign up for social media and online accounts... do we really need another reason to feel like we're being watched? 
... on one hand, I get where the government is coming from - law enforcement agencies do struggle with getting precise location data during investigations. But, forcing phone manufacturers to preinstall a state-run app that can track users' locations 24/7? That's just too much for me 
. And what about people who are genuinely concerned about their security, like journalists or activists? Do they really need their locations tracked all the time? 
. This proposal feels like a step too far, even if it is meant well 
.
and we can't just sit back and let this happen without pushing back 
what's next, going to be forced to carry around some kind of government ID chip? no way man, that's just not right 
. And it's not just about keeping citizens safe from crime, it's about the government getting more power over our lives. Newsflash: we get it, you guys have to deal with bad things happening in your country too, but does that mean we lose all our freedom? I don't think so 
.
.