New York City Teachers Scramble as AI-Powered Cheating Epidemic Spreads
As the new school year unfolds, teachers across New York City are bracing themselves for an AI-fueled cheating epidemic. The rise of artificial intelligence-powered tools has made it increasingly easy for students to bypass traditional academic rigor and submit subpar work.
At Midwood High School, history teacher Michael Dowd is on high alert. He scans student assignments for telltale signs of AI-generated text, such as overly complex vocabulary and formulaic patterns. Dowd's experience with AI detection software has been limited, but he suspects that its reliability will only worsen as the technology advances.
"It's obvious," Dowd says, "but you can't prove it." The frustration is shared by many educators across the city, who feel that policy is lagging behind the rapid evolution of AI. The New York City Department of Education has proposed a vague "framework" for responsible AI use, but critics argue that it is too vague and lacks concrete guidelines.
The absence of clear policies has led to a proliferation of shortcuts and outright cheating. Teachers report seeing students submit papers with phrases like "the Cuban Rocket Emergency" or "Chief Bird of Prey," which are clearly AI-generated. Even veteran educators like Mike Stivers, a science teacher at Millennium High School, are struggling to detect AI-powered cheating.
"I wish they were more forcefully condemning the use of AI for students," Stivers says. "We have no idea what these tools will do to our students' brains over the long term and by embracing them, we put students' development at risk."
In response to the growing crisis, some elected officials are pushing for stricter regulations on AI use in schools. Assemblymember Robert Carroll has introduced legislation to ban AI-powered cheating in most kindergarten through eighth-grade classrooms.
Meanwhile, the American Federation of Teachers is launching educator trainings with tech companies, including a call for protecting student and staff privacy, human jobs, and the environment. However, some teachers worry that these partnerships may be a Trojan horse for the further intrusion of AI into schools.
For students like Bronx Science senior Keir Horne, who uses AI mostly as a study aid, the issue is more nuanced. "It's really good for organizing information," he says. "But I know that kids will use it to cheat when they can."
As the debate over AI-powered cheating continues to unfold, one thing is clear: teachers and educators must stay vigilant in the face of this rapidly evolving threat.
As the new school year unfolds, teachers across New York City are bracing themselves for an AI-fueled cheating epidemic. The rise of artificial intelligence-powered tools has made it increasingly easy for students to bypass traditional academic rigor and submit subpar work.
At Midwood High School, history teacher Michael Dowd is on high alert. He scans student assignments for telltale signs of AI-generated text, such as overly complex vocabulary and formulaic patterns. Dowd's experience with AI detection software has been limited, but he suspects that its reliability will only worsen as the technology advances.
"It's obvious," Dowd says, "but you can't prove it." The frustration is shared by many educators across the city, who feel that policy is lagging behind the rapid evolution of AI. The New York City Department of Education has proposed a vague "framework" for responsible AI use, but critics argue that it is too vague and lacks concrete guidelines.
The absence of clear policies has led to a proliferation of shortcuts and outright cheating. Teachers report seeing students submit papers with phrases like "the Cuban Rocket Emergency" or "Chief Bird of Prey," which are clearly AI-generated. Even veteran educators like Mike Stivers, a science teacher at Millennium High School, are struggling to detect AI-powered cheating.
"I wish they were more forcefully condemning the use of AI for students," Stivers says. "We have no idea what these tools will do to our students' brains over the long term and by embracing them, we put students' development at risk."
In response to the growing crisis, some elected officials are pushing for stricter regulations on AI use in schools. Assemblymember Robert Carroll has introduced legislation to ban AI-powered cheating in most kindergarten through eighth-grade classrooms.
Meanwhile, the American Federation of Teachers is launching educator trainings with tech companies, including a call for protecting student and staff privacy, human jobs, and the environment. However, some teachers worry that these partnerships may be a Trojan horse for the further intrusion of AI into schools.
For students like Bronx Science senior Keir Horne, who uses AI mostly as a study aid, the issue is more nuanced. "It's really good for organizing information," he says. "But I know that kids will use it to cheat when they can."
As the debate over AI-powered cheating continues to unfold, one thing is clear: teachers and educators must stay vigilant in the face of this rapidly evolving threat.
I feel bad for these teachers trying to figure out what's real and what's not. But at the same time, I get it - AI can be super helpful for studying too. I think we need some clearer guidelines on how much AI is okay to use in schools so students don't end up cheating. Like, what's a fair balance between using tools to help and just plain cheating? It's not an easy one to solve. Maybe the answer is to focus on teaching critical thinking skills instead of just regurgitating facts? 
. It's like, we gotta protect our kids from gettin' burned by these tools. I remember when we didn't have Google, and we actually had to use encyclopedias and books to do research... that was hard work, but it was worth it in the end. Nowadays, it's all about cheatin' and gettin' an easy A 
. Gotta keep those educators on their toes, fer sure!
That sounds like a recipe for disaster if you ask me! And I'm not buying into the whole "AI is just a tool" vibe. We need to be careful about how we deploy this tech in our schools.
We don't want to stifle innovation or limit students' access to tools that can actually help them succeed. But at the same time, we've got to make sure our educators have the training and resources they need to keep pace with this changing landscape.
We need to have a more nuanced conversation about how AI is going to change our education system for good (or bad). And let's not forget, this isn't just about students – it's also about the educators who are on the frontlines of this battle. They deserve our support and solidarity! 
it's like they're stuck between a rock and a hard place - on one hand, they wanna support their students with AI as a study aid, but on the other hand, they can't let them use it to cheat 
so many schools are just winging it here, i wish there was more clarity on how to handle this whole thing 
what's crazy is that these AI tools are getting smarter and better at generating text, making it harder for teachers to detect 
got me thinking - what's the real cost of progress here? We're so quick to adopt new tech without considering the long-term effects on our students' learning experience. I mean, don't get me wrong, AI can be a game-changer for organization and study tools... but when it comes to cheating, that's just not cool 
.
. Newsflash: that's not gonna cut it.
. Robert Carroll's legislation is a good start, but we need more concrete policies on the books. And what about the funding for these AI-detection software and educator trainings? It's like they're expecting teachers to volunteer their time and resources without any compensation 
.
, it's just not fair to other students who put in the actual effort 
. But at the same time, I don't think we should just ban AI tools entirely 
As a teacher myself, I'd want to teach them the value of hard work and critical thinking skills, not just how to whip out an AI-powered essay generator 
. But you know what? Maybe this is an opportunity for us to rethink our whole education system and make sure we're focusing on what really matters: preparing students for the real world, not just for some standardized test or AI-powered cheat sheet 
Schools are trying to keep up with these AI tools, but it's hard when there's no clear policy in place. Some teachers are using software to detect cheating, but it's like playing a game of whack-a-mole – the cheats just keep coming back. 
. So, let's get a grip and figure out a solution that works for everyone 
they're literally having to babysit 14 yr olds all day lol idk how they deal with it... AI-powered cheating is like, soooo not fair 
my cousin went through high school and she had some experience with this too, and it was super frustrating for her because teachers were always suspecting her of cheating even when she wasn't. anyway i feel for the new york city teachers who are literally fighting an uphill battle here 