Opinion: Why is ‘60 Minutes’ amplifying the views of Marjorie Taylor Greene? | CNN

"CBS' '60 Minutes' is in a tight spot after hosting Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene on the show, with many critics arguing that the long-running news program is inadvertently amplifying her divisive and often hateful views.

For years, CBS has prided itself on featuring controversial guests on its popular program, including Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh and Iran's Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini. However, this week's interview with Greene is a different story altogether.

Despite being a prominent Republican who has been involved in several controversies, including speaking at a white nationalist event last year, CBS host Lesley Stahl failed to address some of the more concerning aspects of Greene's past behavior and views. For example, she didn't mention that Greene had chanted "Jews are not welcome" outside the U.S. Capitol after the 2018 Parkland school shooting or that she had called a survivor of the same shooting "#littleHitler".

Greene's appearance on the show was seen as a missed opportunity to hold her accountable for some of her more egregious statements and actions, particularly those related to anti-Semitism and her support for QAnon. The fact that she got to praise CBS host Stahl while misspelling her name only added to the criticism.

Critics argue that "60 Minutes" is now using its platform to give a platform to far-right figures like Greene in order to boost ratings, a sentiment echoed by former Rep. Adam Kinzinger and journalist Molly Jong-Fast. The latter called it "spending its currency on the Jewish space lasers woman", while Hogg from Parkland responded to Stahl's interview saying he was looking forward to her questions about why she thinks school shootings are fake.

Greene, however, came across as genuinely appreciative of the show, praising Stahl and calling her a "legendary icon". But this comes at a cost – the program may be pandering to Greene's divisive views without critically examining them. The fact that CBS had not responded to CNN's request for comment on this issue adds fuel to the fire.

CBS has long prided itself on its commitment to journalism, but this week's "60 Minutes" episode highlights the blurred lines between giving a platform to prominent figures and merely seeking clicks. Moonves' infamous comments from 2016 about being drawn to Trump's candidacy as a good business opportunity may be gone, but his mindset seems to have stuck with some of his colleagues at CBS. It remains to be seen how "60 Minutes" will balance its desire for controversy with its commitment to journalism and critical thinking.
 
🤔 I'm really disappointed in the way this interview went down. They're trying to play both sides, but it's all just a distraction from the real issues at hand. Greene is still spewing hate speech and anti-Semitic rhetoric, and no one wants to touch that. 🚫 Meanwhile, Lesley Stahl is just going through the motions without asking any tough questions. It's like they're trying to boost ratings by giving her a platform instead of holding her accountable for her words.

I mean, come on, if you're gonna have a far-right figure like Greene on your show, at least make sure you ask some hard-hitting questions. Don't just let her coast through without being challenged. It's not fair to the audience or to Greene herself. We need more in-depth analysis and critical thinking from programs like "60 Minutes". 💡 Otherwise, they're just pandering to clicks and controversy instead of doing real journalism.

CBS is trying to distance themselves from Moonves' past comments, but I think this interview shows that some of his old mindset has stuck around. They need to get back to their roots and focus on telling real stories with critical thinking. Anything less feels like clickbait. 🤦‍♀️
 
man I'm so confused about this whole thing 🤔... like I get that CBS is trying to feature all sorts of guests, but Rep Greene's views are just super concerning 🙅‍♀️... I mean I've heard she's been to some weird events, like that white nationalist thing last year... and what was up with her chanting "Jews not welcome" outside the Capitol? that's straight up hate 🤬... and don't even get me started on the QAnon stuff 😳... but at the same time I feel like CBS is just trying to boost ratings by letting her spout off on live TV 📺... it's all about clicks, right? 🤑... but can they really just ignore the hate speech and anti-Semitism? that's not journalism, that's just bad news 📰...
 
omg i'm so sad to hear that marjorie taylor greene got a platform on 60 minutes 🤕 lesley stahl should've called her out on those hateful comments she made about jews and parkland survivors ... it's like cbs is just giving her a free pass and boosting ratings at the expense of actual journalism 📺👎 i can imagine how frustrating it must be for people who lost loved ones in those school shootings to see their pain and anger dismissed on tv 😢
 
🤔 the thing is, they're all about getting clicks right? they want controversy, they want drama, and now they've got Greene spewing her hate on live TV 📺. it's not like they didn't know what she was capable of before inviting her on the show. I mean, come on, "Jews are not welcome"? that's some serious red flag stuff 🔴. and don't even get me started on the praise from Greene towards Stahl - what a sell-out 🤑. it's all about ratings for them now, and I'm not buying it 💸. moonves may be gone, but his DNA is still in there, and it's just not healthy for journalism 👎
 
🤷‍♀️ I mean, can you even blame them? They're a news program, not a debate show. They want to feature interesting guests, but sometimes that means inviting people who are gonna stir up the pot. Greene's definitely got some... let's say "strong" opinions 😒. But hey, at least she's consistent, right? And to be fair, Stahl did ask some pretty softball questions 🤔. I mean, no one likes to talk about their own controversies, but come on, that's what these shows are for! It's not like they're gonna cancel her tour or something 🚫. Maybe next time they'll dig a bit deeper, but I wouldn't count on it 😂.
 
I'm shocked they actually thought they could just give Marjorie Taylor Greene a platform without scrutinizing her views 🙄. I mean, come on, she's been involved in some seriously hate-filled rhetoric, including anti-Semitism and QAnon, which is basically a cult 🤯. And Lesley Stahl barely touched on any of that during the interview, just glossing over it like it was no big deal 🙅‍♀️.

Meanwhile, CBS is worried about its ratings 📺, which I think is a pretty weak reason to give a platform to someone who's basically a far-right firebrand 🔥. It's not like they're helping themselves by pandering to these kinds of views – it just makes them look bad by association 😒.

And let's be real, if they were actually trying to do some journalism, they would've asked her some tough questions about her past behavior and the harm she's caused 🤔. But instead, they just patted her on the head and said "good job" 🙏. I mean, what even is that?
 
I'm so done with this. CBS is playing with fire here, and it's not just Rep. Greene's views that are the problem, but the way they're being presented. I get that they want to have a diverse range of guests, but this feels like a ratings stunt. They know full well what Greene's been saying and doing, so to ignore those parts and just focus on her praise for Lesley Stahl is just lazy. And don't even get me started on the timing - a show that's all about journalism should be pushing back against hate speech, not giving it a platform.

It feels like CBS has lost its way, and this episode is just proof of that. They're more concerned with getting clicks than with actually having a meaningful conversation. And what's with the lack of response from their team? It's like they're trying to avoid accountability. I'm not sure how they're gonna recover from this one. 🤦‍♀️📺
 
omg I'm so torn about this 🤯... on one hand I think it's total bs that they didn't call out all the crazy stuff Greene has said & done 🙄 like what even is up with her channelling "Jews are not welcome" outside the Capitol after Parkland? isn't that literally hate speech? 🤷‍♀️ but on the other hand I kinda get why CBS might've wanted to give her a platform too... it's been a while since they've had a super divisive guest and maybe this is just how they want to stay relevant in the times we're living in 🤑 BUT at the same time, doesn't that mean they're basically pandering to Greene's views without really examining them for their own journalistic integrity? 🤔 I don't know man... I guess I'm just confused 💭
 
I'm really confused about this whole situation 🤔. I get that '60 Minutes' has always tried to feature guests from different sides of the aisle, but this time it feels like they just let Marjorie Taylor Greene talk her way out of some pretty uncomfortable questions 💬. I mean, didn't Lesley Stahl know that Greene's been involved in some super racist and anti-Semitic stuff? It seems like she just glossed over all that to make the interview more palatable 🤷‍♀️.

I'm not sure what's going on with CBS right now - are they really trying to boost ratings by giving a platform to people who are just plain divisive? Because if so, I don't think that's a good idea at all 🙅‍♂️. I know the show has always prided itself on being about journalism and critical thinking, but this week it feels like they just caved to Greene's rhetoric 💸.

I'm not sure what's next for '60 Minutes' - will they start featuring more people like Greene? It seems like a slippery slope 🤯. I hope they can figure out how to balance being provocative with being responsible and critical 🤔.
 
🤔 [diagram of a seesaw]
CBS' 60 Minutes is in a tricky spot 🤷‍♀️ after hosting Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene on the show. On one side, it's been known to feature controversial guests in the past, but this time they didn't address some concerning aspects of her views and actions 🚫. They didn't mention her anti-Semitic comments or her support for QAnon 🤥.

On the other hand, the show is also trying to balance giving a platform to prominent figures with seeking clicks and ratings 📊. This might lead them to miss out on critical questions about Greene's views 🤔.
I think it's like this [diagram of a circle]:
platform >>>>>> clickbait
but what if they focus on the middle part? 🤝

Criticisms are valid, but we need more nuanced conversations 🗣️.
 
i feel like 60 minutes is just trying too hard to be edgy & provocative... they know they're gonna get slammed by the left & the right, so they'll put on someone like Greene just to stir the pot 🤔. news shouldn't be about clickbait, it should be about informing us. they need to go back to the drawing board and do some real journalism, not just a quick interview with a polarizing figure 😒.
 
🤔 I think 60 minutes is in a weird spot now, they've been doing provocative guests for years but this one feels different... like they're more interested in getting attention than really having a tough conversation 📺. They should have asked Greene about some of the crazy stuff she's said and done, like that #littleHitler comment 🙅‍♀️. It's not like she's being open-minded or anything, she's still spouting hate speech 🚫. I don't get why they let her praise Stahl without correcting her on purpose 🤷‍♀️. Now everyone's saying they're just trying to boost ratings by playing into the controversy 📈. Not cool 😒
 
🤔 I'm shocked that CBS didn't do more to fact-check Rep Greene's claims, especially given the harm she's caused in the past 🙅‍♀️. It's like they wanted to give her a platform to spew her hate without being held accountable 🚫. The whole thing felt really staged, like they were trying to get a rise out of Hogg and Parkland survivors 👀. I mean, come on, Lesley Stahl should've known better than to let Greene praise her without calling her out on her views 💁‍♀️. It's not just about giving a platform to controversy, it's about holding people accountable for their actions 🤝. Can't CBS do better than this? 😐
 
🤔 I'm not sure if CBS is trying to boost ratings by giving a platform to people like Marjorie Taylor Greene, but it does feel like they're walking a fine line between being neutral and letting her spew her toxic views all over the place. They did try to hold her accountable for some of her statements, but I think they could've done more. I mean, who gets to praise their interviewer while misspelling their name? 🙄 It's not like Greene is a hard person to criticize – she's been involved in some pretty shady stuff and has made some seriously hurtful comments about certain groups. The fact that CBS didn't address those things more thoroughly is concerning.

As for the criticism from Adam Kinzinger and Molly Jong-Fast, I think they're right on point. It does feel like "60 Minutes" is trying to be all things to all people and isn't willing to take a hard stance against someone who's just so clearly divisive. And the lack of comment from CBS about this issue doesn't help – it's like they're trying to avoid the controversy altogether.

I'm not sure what the solution is here, but I think "60 Minutes" needs to find a better way to balance its desire for controversy with its commitment to journalism and critical thinking. Maybe that means taking more risks in questioning the guests they feature? 🤷‍♂️
 
I'm really disappointed in this recent episode of 60 minutes 🤕😔 I know they've had controversy guests before but this one feels different. They didn't even bring up some super concerning stuff about Rep Greene's past behavior. It just felt like a soft question session to me 💁‍♀️👀 And what was with the praise for Lesley Stahl, got to love her but come on 🙄 CBS usually does better than this 😔
 
Back
Top