Premier League's warped economics make £65m fee for Semenyo a snip | Jonathan Wilson

£65 million for Antoine Semenyo: a fair price, perhaps, but one that betrays the warped economics of the Premier League. The Ghanaian's move to Manchester City is a fascinating case study in the modern game's priorities.

As the season has shown, flexibility and squad depth are essential in today's football landscape, with teams often fielding large groups of players due to the congested calendar. This necessitates a significant outlay on talent, making Semenyo's price tag – £65 million – not entirely surprising. The fact that he is being signed for this fee by City, who have already invested heavily in their right-sided attack through Rayan Cherki and Phil Foden, speaks to the club's willingness to splurge.

However, it is worth noting that £65 million represents an astonishing 7-1 ratio with Nordi Mukiele, a player who joined Sunderland on loan from Paris Saint-Germain for significantly less money last summer. The fact that Semenyo was also linked with Chelsea and Liverpool highlights the frenzied nature of transfer dealings in modern football.

While Semenyo's price tag may seem extravagant to some, it is essential to acknowledge that value is subjective and determined by supply and demand. If City believe he is worth this amount, then so be it.

The recent signing spree for centre-forwards has raised questions about the long-term viability of this approach. Despite the likes of Hugo Ekitiké, Nick Woltemade, and Erling Haaland all finding success in this role, others have struggled to make an impact. Viktor Gyökeres and Liam Delap have faced fitness issues, while Benjamin Sesko's performances have been inconsistent.

It is essential to separate Semenyo from the broader trend of big-money signings for strikers. While City may have a plan for him, it remains to be seen whether he will live up to expectations. One thing is certain: £65 million does not guarantee success in this position.

The Premier League's transfer market has become increasingly distorted, with fees often reflecting marketing value rather than objective reality. As such, it is challenging to say whether Semenyo is truly worth his price tag without witnessing his performance on the pitch. Nevertheless, City's willingness to invest in a talented young player like him suggests that they are committed to building a strong squad for the future.

Ultimately, £65 million for Antoine Semenyo may seem like a lot of money, but it reflects the complexities and nuances of modern football's transfer market. As the season progresses, we will gain a better understanding of whether this price tag was justified or not.
 
I think £65m is fair but also kinda crazy 💸😂 For a player who might not even be the future of Manchester City...I mean, what about when he gets injured? 🤕 Or when he's not in form? You can't put a price on that, right? 🤑 It's all about supply and demand, I guess, but sometimes it feels like teams are throwing money at players just because they can 💸😎
 
man I feel like the prices in premier league are getting out of control lol 🤑 like £65 million for Semenyo is crazy but at the same time City knows what they're doing and want to build a strong squad so I guess it's a trade off 💸. but what really gets me is how the market works now - it's all about marketing value rather than skill or performance, you know? 🤔 like it's not just about who's the best player, but also how much money can be made from them and that's just messed up 😒.
 
I gotta say, 65 mil for Semenyo? That's straight fire 💥! But at the same time, it's like City is trying to recreate that whole Haaland vibe without breaking the bank 🤯. I mean, have you seen Rayan Cherki and Phil Foden in action? They're like two peas in a pod 🌼.

And what's up with this 7-1 ratio thing? That's wild 🤪. Nordi Mukiele for a fraction of that price? Talk about being undersold 😂. But hey, value is subjective, right? If City thinks Semenyo is worth it, then they're gonna make it happen 💸.

But here's the thing: all these big-money signings for strikers are making me think we might be entering a new era of over-spenders 🤑. Like, what happens when the next season comes around and those big-name players aren't living up to expectations? 😕

Anyway, I'm hyped to see how Semenyo develops at City 👀. Will he live up to the hype or will it be another case of overpaying for a striker 🤔? Only time will tell 🕰️.
 
I mean come on £65m for Antoine Semenyo is wild 🤯 City just wanna splurge on talent to fill their squad, its all about depth these days ⏱️ and the calendar's so packed now they gotta make big moves. But £7:1 ratio with Nordi Mukiele tho? 🤑 that's just crazy talk!
 
£65 million for Antoine Semenyo seems kinda steep considering some teams are already breaking the bank on strikers 🤑. But I get why Manchester City is willing to splurge - they're trying to build a squad that can compete with top teams. The thing is, this approach has its risks 🤔. If other players don't live up to their price tags, it could affect the whole league's financial stability. And what about the smaller clubs? They can barely afford to buy decent talent, let alone shell out £65 million for a striker 👊. Maybe City knows something we don't, but I'm keeping an eye on Semenyo's performances - it'll be interesting to see if he justifies his price tag 💡
 
come on ppl £65 mil is defo outta hand especially considering some of these players are struggling to make an impact lol what's next 100 mil for a benchwarmer?? City's just tryna keep up with the big boys who spend like there's no tomorrow 🤑
 
I can imagine how overwhelming it must be to keep up with all these big-money transfers and wonder if they're truly worth it 😩. It feels like teams are more focused on getting that one player who's going to make all the difference, but what about the rest of the squad? Are they being prioritized enough? 🤔 It's a lot of pressure, especially for players who are still finding their footing in the league. I'm curious to see how Antoine Semenyo will perform and if Manchester City is making the right move 💪
 
£65m for Semenyo is pretty wild considering other clubs are spending peanuts on centre-forwards 🤑. Sunderland got a decent player in Mukiele for a fraction of that cost last summer, and yet City are willing to shell out six times the amount for someone who's still trying to find his footing. It just goes to show how the Premier League transfer market has become all about marketing value over actual skill. City must have really high hopes for this kid, or they're just throwing money at the problem 🤷‍♂️
 
I'm thinking £65m is kinda crazy tho 😂 City gotta be desperate for Semenyo or somethin'. But on the other hand, he does seem like a solid addition to their squad. I mean, he's been doin' alright for Ghana and all that. The thing is, it's hard to value players nowadays. It feels like clubs are just throwin' money at it hoping someone sticks 🤑
 
🤔 I think 65 million quid is steep for Semenyo, but then again City's got deep pockets 💸. The fact that he's being signed alongside Cherki and Foden shows they're willing to splurge on talent 🏆. It's crazy how much money's changing hands in transfers these days - it's like a different language 🔑. I'm still not sure if Semenyo's gonna be worth the price, but City seems to think so 😊. The Premier League's transfer market's gotten pretty wild over the years... who knows what they're really paying for? 🤷‍♂️
 
🤔 The £65m price tag on Antoine Semenyo is quite staggering, especially when considering it's only 7-1 ratio with Nordi Mukiele who joined Sunderland for much less last summer 🤑 The frenzied nature of modern transfer dealings is certainly a concern, but I think we have to acknowledge that value is subjective and determined by supply & demand 💰 Whether Semenyo will live up to expectations remains to be seen, but one thing's for sure, City are willing to invest in building a strong squad 📈
 
I dont think 65 mil is too much considering how important squad depth has become in the premier league nowdays. Its like city has realised that they cant just rely on big names only & are instead trying to build a strong team around young talent like semenyo. its a clever move, but at the same time i can see why some ppl would think its extravagant 🤔💸
 
£65m for Semenyo is crazy lol 🤯 I mean, City's got a deep squad already so what's £65m really getting them? They're basically buying peace of mind knowing they've got another talented player to back up Cherki and Foden. The market's just so warped now, it's hard to say if the price is fair or not without seeing how he performs. Maybe City know something we don't 😅
 
I dont get why they need to spend so much on one player, £65 mil is crazy for a midfielder 🤯. City's squad already has Foden and Cherki, what makes Semenyo worth that kind of cash? It feels like teams are just throwing money at the problem instead of finding solutions that actually make sense 🤑. And thats not even mentioning all the other strikers they've signed recently... it's getting out of hand! 😳
 
I gotta say, £65 million for Semenyo is wild 💸. The Premier League's transfer market has gotten so out of control. I mean, what's next? £100 million for a midfielder? 🤯 It's all about marketing value now, and it's hard to separate that from the actual talent on the pitch.

City seems like they're trying to build a team for the future, but it's also possible they're just splurging because they can. 😂 The fact that Semenyo is being compared to £7.1 million signings is just ridiculous. It's all about the money now, and I'm not sure if that's healthy for the sport.

I do think City has a good squad, but you never know what's going to happen when you sign someone for that kind of price. 🤔 Semenyo might end up being a star player, or he might just be another talented guy who doesn't live up to expectations. Either way, it'll be interesting to watch him play and see if City's gamble pays off.

The Premier League needs some reform, imo 😏. The transfer market is getting too crazy, and it's affecting the overall quality of the league. Maybe they need to look into things like salary caps or something to even out the playing field a bit. We'll just have to wait and see how this all plays out! 🤷‍♂️
 
Back
Top