Whether or not Trump invades Greenland, this much is clear: the western order we once knew is history | Timothy Garton Ash

"Western Order in Shambles: Europe Must Adapt to a Post-Western World"

The specter of Donald Trump's invasion of Greenland hangs over the world like a dark cloud, casting a shadow on the very foundations of international relations. While it remains to be seen whether Trump will actually follow through on his threat, one thing is certain: the Western order that once brought stability and cooperation among nations is rapidly unraveling.

A recent global public opinion poll provides a chilling glimpse into the state of public perception in Europe and beyond. Conducted by the European Council on Foreign Relations and the University of Oxford, the poll reveals a stark decline in faith in the West's institutions and values. Less than one in five Europeans believe that the US is an ally, while only 18% in Ukraine still see it as such.

The Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022 marked a turning point, as China, India, and Turkey continued to engage with Russia despite Western sanctions. However, Trump's presidency has taken this trend further. His approach is eerily similar to that of Vladimir Putin, prioritizing strength, force, and power over diplomacy and cooperation.

In response, Europeans must adapt to a new reality where the West is no longer the dominant player on the global stage. The traditional rules-based international system is rapidly losing credibility, and old alliances are being rewritten. The EU, in particular, faces an existential challenge as its slow-moving institutions struggle to keep pace with the demands of a rapidly changing world.

Garton Ash's prescription for Europe is clear: it must adopt a new internationalism that prioritizes power, pragmatism, and results over rules and process. This means engaging with a wider range of partners on issue-by-issue basis, embracing flexibility and adaptability, and demonstrating quiet strength and resolve in the face of adversity.

A series of high-profile visits to Greenland are just the beginning. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, French President Emmanuel Macron, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, and others should join forces to send a clear message that Europe will not be intimidated by Trump's aggression.

The strategic discussion between Greenland and the EU on a possible close relationship is also long overdue. A customized partnership with Greenland could provide a vital counterbalance to Russia's growing influence in the Arctic region.

As the world hurtles towards a post-Western order, Europeans must steel themselves for a new era of uncertainty and competition. The poll's dismal findings – that half of Europeans are pessimistic about the EU's ability to deal on equal terms with global powers – only underscore the need for a more assertive and proactive approach.

Ultimately, the fate of Greenland hangs in the balance, as Trump's erratic behavior and Putin's growing belligerence threaten to upset the delicate balance of power in the region. Europe must respond with calm deliberation, but also with unwavering resolve and determination to defend its values and interests. The world is watching, and the West can no longer afford to sleepwalk into oblivion.
 
Europe needs to step up their game πŸ”„πŸ’ͺ, these leaders are just talking trash about Trump, but it's time for them to put their money where their mouth is πŸ’ΈπŸ‘Š, Greenland is literally a pawn in a global game of chess and the EU can't afford to lose control of it 🀯🌎
 
πŸ€” I gotta say, this whole Western order thing feels like it's been on life support for ages anyway. Like, we all knew Trump was gonna be a wild card, but even Putin's moves feel like they're just trying to shake things up at this point.

The EU is already in crisis mode, and the idea of them trying to reinvent themselves as some sort of "new internationalism" feels kinda laughable to me. I mean, we've been stuck on autopilot for years, watching Russia and China flex their muscles while we're still debating whether to invest in green energy or not.

Garton Ash's advice is spot on – we need to get our act together and start adapting to a world where the US isn't the default superpower anymore. But it's also time for us to stop being so weak-willed about it. We can't just wait around for some EU summit to decide what happens next; we need to take charge ourselves.

And let's be real, who are these leaders going to make a pact with? Greenland is literally being used as leverage by Trump and Putin – it's not like they're exactly known for their diplomatic skills. We need to start thinking about our own interests and how to protect them, rather than just trying to maintain some sort of facade.

The fact that half of Europeans are pessimistic about the EU's ability to deal with global powers is a major red flag. It's time for us to wake up and take control of our own destiny – or at least have a conversation about what we want to do next.
 
🀯 I'm still trying to wrap my head around the idea that the Western order is literally unraveling before our eyes πŸŒͺ️. It's like we're all stuck in some kind of global video game where the rules keep changing and everyone's just trying to adapt πŸ’».

The fact that less than 1 in 5 Europeans believe the US is an ally is wild 🀯. I mean, I've been saying this for years – the West has become so used to being dominant that we've lost touch with what's really important 🌎.

Garton Ash's idea of adopting a new internationalism that prioritizes power and pragmatism over rules and process feels like the only way forward πŸš€. We need Europe (and the world) to be more flexible, adaptable, and willing to take risks πŸ’ͺ.

The Greenland situation is super interesting – I think it's time we started having some real conversations about what kind of relationship we want with the EU versus Russia 🀝. A customized partnership could be a game-changer in the Arctic region ❄️.

Ultimately, Europe needs to wake up and start taking charge of its own destiny πŸ’ͺ. We can't just sit back and watch the world change without us – that's not leadership, that's just being reactive 😴.
 
Europe needs to get real about China's growing influence, btw they're already making moves in Africa and Asia. Trump's all about drama, but Putin's the one with the real power in Russia πŸ€”πŸ’‘. The EU needs a new strategy, not just a bunch of empty promises about being strong and united πŸ’ͺ🏽. They need to show China (and everyone else) that they're serious about adapting to a post-Western world. Can't just keep relying on the US to bail them out πŸ™…β€β™‚οΈ. A more assertive approach, like Garton Ash suggests, is long overdue. Time for Europe to step up its game and show the world what it's made of πŸ’₯!
 
trump's actions are like a ripple effect across the globe 🌎, making europe question their own strength & values. the idea of a post-western world isn't new, but trump's presidency has sped up that transition ⏱️. for europe to adapt, they need to think differently about power & pragmatism over rules & process πŸ’‘. it's time for them to engage with other global powers on an issue-by-issue basis, and show quiet strength in the face of adversity πŸ”₯. the fact that half of europeans are pessimistic about the eu's ability to deal with global powers is worrying πŸ€”. it's time for europe to wake up & take charge, not just sleepwalk into oblivion 😴.
 
πŸ€” I think this whole Western order thing is kinda like my garden, you know? It's been neglected for a while, now it's all withered and dying πŸŒ±πŸ’”. Trump and Putin are just like those pesky weeds that need to be pulled out - they're choking the life out of everything.

What Europe needs is a good dose of DIY magic ✨! They should start by revamping their own backyard before trying to fix everyone else's πŸ πŸ‘. It's all about being flexible, adapting, and embracing what works for them, not just relying on old rules and institutions.

And let's be real, they need to stop worrying so much about what others think πŸ€·β€β™€οΈ. They should focus on building strong relationships with partners who actually share their values πŸ’•, like those in Greenland or Canada. A customized partnership could be the key to countering Russia's influence in the Arctic 🚒.

Europe needs to take charge of its own destiny and show the world that it's still a force to be reckoned with πŸ”₯! No more sleepwalking into oblivion 😴 - they need to wake up, get organized, and start making moves πŸ’ͺ. That's how you build a strong foundation for a post-Western world 🌟.
 
So Trump's all like wanna take over Greenland and it's super scary? πŸ€” I mean I get it, Europe's gotta step up its game 'cause the West ain't what it used to be. But isn't Greenland kinda small for a major power play? Like wouldn't that just make everyone lose interest in Greenland altogether? And what about all these other countries like China and India who are already chillin' with Russia? Wouldn't they be like "Uh, no thanks" if the EU's all up in Trump's grill over Greenland?

And I don't get why Garton Ash is saying we gotta adopt this whole new internationalism thing. Like what does that even mean? Sounds super vague to me. Is he talking about more diplomatic channels or just being more chill with Russia and China? And how do we know it's not just a bunch of EU politicians playing games like "Let's see who can be the most pro-US" without actually getting anything done?

Also, has anyone thought about what would happen if Greenland just decided to go solo like that? Like, if Trump and Putin are both trying to take over, wouldn't Greenland be all "Uh, no thanks, I'm good"? πŸ€·β€β™€οΈ
 
Back
Top