Trump Administration's Mass Deportation Agenda Takes Hit as Eight Judges Fired in New York City
The Trump administration has made good on its vow to speed up deportations by firing eight immigration judges in New York City, further depleting an already beleaguered system. The firings, which have left the city's main immigration court severely understaffed, are part of a nationwide shake-up of the immigration bench that aims to quell record case backlogs.
According to sources, all eight judges fired worked out of 26 Federal Plaza in Lower Manhattan, where the city's main immigration court and local headquarters for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) are located. The dismissal includes an assistant chief immigration judge who oversaw colleagues at the courthouse.
The move is part of a broader effort by the administration to ramp up enforcement, following recent escalations in rhetoric on immigration after a shooting near the White House that involved an Afghan national. Trump has vowed to halt migration from "all Third World Countries" and position tougher enforcement and faster removals as central to his second-term agenda.
Critics argue that this move will exacerbate an already dire situation. The Immigration Court backlog has reached over 3.7 million pending cases nationwide, with immigration attorneys warning that the dismissals will add years to asylum timelines. "The court has been basically eviscerated," said Olivia Cassin, a former New York judge. "It feels like a Monday afternoon massacre."
Former federal immigration judges have expressed similar concerns, noting that firings and forced departures have added years to wait times in asylum cases. One judge who spoke to Newsweek anonymously warned of potential delays into 2028: "I already had a backlog where I was filled for 2027... You're looking at years of delay of cases because you're removing judges from the courtroom."
The immediate consequence of this move is likely to be more delays for people waiting years for their day in court, even as Trump and his allies insist they are attempting to speed up deportations. Immigration attorneys have previously warned that recruiting and training new judges can take at least a year.
As the administration pushes forward with its deportation agenda, concerns about due process in immigration courts grow. Critics argue that cutting experienced adjudicators while implementing mass enforcement measures risks undermining the very fabric of the immigration system.
The Trump administration has made good on its vow to speed up deportations by firing eight immigration judges in New York City, further depleting an already beleaguered system. The firings, which have left the city's main immigration court severely understaffed, are part of a nationwide shake-up of the immigration bench that aims to quell record case backlogs.
According to sources, all eight judges fired worked out of 26 Federal Plaza in Lower Manhattan, where the city's main immigration court and local headquarters for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) are located. The dismissal includes an assistant chief immigration judge who oversaw colleagues at the courthouse.
The move is part of a broader effort by the administration to ramp up enforcement, following recent escalations in rhetoric on immigration after a shooting near the White House that involved an Afghan national. Trump has vowed to halt migration from "all Third World Countries" and position tougher enforcement and faster removals as central to his second-term agenda.
Critics argue that this move will exacerbate an already dire situation. The Immigration Court backlog has reached over 3.7 million pending cases nationwide, with immigration attorneys warning that the dismissals will add years to asylum timelines. "The court has been basically eviscerated," said Olivia Cassin, a former New York judge. "It feels like a Monday afternoon massacre."
Former federal immigration judges have expressed similar concerns, noting that firings and forced departures have added years to wait times in asylum cases. One judge who spoke to Newsweek anonymously warned of potential delays into 2028: "I already had a backlog where I was filled for 2027... You're looking at years of delay of cases because you're removing judges from the courtroom."
The immediate consequence of this move is likely to be more delays for people waiting years for their day in court, even as Trump and his allies insist they are attempting to speed up deportations. Immigration attorneys have previously warned that recruiting and training new judges can take at least a year.
As the administration pushes forward with its deportation agenda, concerns about due process in immigration courts grow. Critics argue that cutting experienced adjudicators while implementing mass enforcement measures risks undermining the very fabric of the immigration system.
this is wild fam... think they're gonna speed up deportations by firing judges? it's like, what's next? having cops show up at people's doors to start arresting them for being undocumented 
i mean, the backlog already got over 3.7 million cases - can't we just slow down on this deportation train and focus on getting those cases resolved somehow? it's like they're trying to create a system that's gonna push people into homelessness or worse 
it's like they want us to suffer in silence... i feel bad for all those ppl waiting years for their day in court 
the system is already broken what's next? more firings and less judges? 
this is not gonna end well
. I mean, who needs eight judges to speed up deportations? It's like they think people are just gonna magically show up in court and be ready for a hearing overnight 
. The thing is, judges aren't just paper pushers, they're the ones making decisions that can change lives. And now you're taking away experienced ones who know what they're doing? It's not exactly a recipe for speed.
. And let's be real, this whole thing feels like it's all about politics and rhetoric rather than actually solving problems 
.
.
! Firing 8 judges in NYC is like, totally gonna mess up asylum timelines for years to come 
. What's next? Are they gonna start making people wait even longer for their court dates just because it's a "Monday afternoon massacre"? 
Not cool, guys 
.
. We need to support our judges and make sure they're equipped to handle these cases, not get rid of them! 
. I mean, do they really think that by removing experienced judges from the court, people will get their cases processed faster? It's like thinking you can speed up a traffic jam by taking away all the cops 
. The backlog of immigration cases is already insane (3.7 million!), and now it's going to take years longer for people to even get a hearing. This move is just gonna cause more problems and make due process a distant memory 
.
That's just not how this works.
. It's just gonna lead to more chaos and suffering for innocent people trying to seek asylum 
. Can't we just take a step back and try to find some common sense here? 
