Caught up in a violent attack, would you be a hero – or would you run? Both can be valuable | Emma Kavanagh

The age-old question: what if I were in that situation, facing danger and uncertainty? Would I be able to rise to the occasion as a hero, or would I succumb to fear and flee?

For some of us, it's easy to imagine ourselves as champions, bravely charging into harm's way to save others. But for many, the reality is more complex. Our bodies respond with "fight or flight," but our brains are wired for social connection and community, too.

In emergency situations, people often want to help – but fear can also be a powerful motivator. According to psychologist Emma Kavanagh, who has worked with police and military personnel, removing ourselves from danger is the rational thing to do initially. "Fear is sensible," she writes. "Flight is adaptive."

However, once we've escaped harm's way, our instincts kick in, and our natural response becomes one of tenderness and compassion. We want to help those who need it most.

So, what determines whether someone will be a hero or flee? For some, it's all about self-image – have they imagined themselves as heroes before? Research shows that schemas, mental models we've created in our minds, play a crucial role in shaping our behavior during crises. If we believe we'll be the one to save the day, we're more likely to act on it.

Another key factor is experience. Those who have navigated previous emergencies often find they can manage their fear response better and function effectively under pressure.

Lastly, how closely do we identify with being a force for good in the world? If we consider ourselves to be people who make a positive impact, we're more likely to want to help others during an emergency.

The truth is that disasters move quickly, and our immediate response can be chaotic. But even in the darkest moments, there's hope for recovery and growth. Research suggests that many survivors of traumatic events experience post-traumatic growth – they emerge stronger, wiser, and more compassionate as a result of their ordeal.

So, what would you do if faced with danger? Would you rise to the occasion or flee? It's not a simple question, but by understanding our complex motivations and behaviors in emergency situations, we can work towards being better, more compassionate versions of ourselves.
 
🤔 I mean, like, what if you were actually facing danger and stuff... would you be all brave and save people or just run away? 😂 I think it's kinda funny that our brains are wired for both fight or flight and social connection... like, we wanna help others but also don't wanna die. 🤷‍♀️

I wonder if anyone has actually done any research on what makes someone a hero in emergency situations... it sounds like it's got to do with self-image and experience... but what about people who are just kinda normal and don't really think they're heroes? 🤔 Would they still want to help?

And, um, isn't post-traumatic growth actually a thing now? Like, did I read that right? People can grow stronger and wiser after traumatic experiences... that's pretty cool, I guess. 😊
 
Imagine a Venn diagram with two circles: Fear/Flight vs Heroic Action. The overlap between them is where we get stuck. On one side, we have the rational part of us that says "flight is adaptive" and removes us from harm's way. But then we also have our compassionate side that wants to help others.

Think of it like this:
```
+---------------+
| Fear/Flight |
| (Short-term) |
+---------------+
|
| Remove yourself from danger
v
+---------------+
| Heroic Action |
| (Long-term) |
+---------------+

|
| Your mental model of self as a hero
v
+---------------+
| Experience |
| (Learned from past emergencies)|
+---------------+

|
| How closely do you identify with being a force for good?
v
+---------------+
| Self-Compassion |
| (Positive impact on self and others) |
+---------------+
```
It's not always easy to decide which side of the Venn diagram we want to be on. But by understanding our complex motivations, we can work towards being better versions of ourselves 🤝💡
 
idk about this article lol 🤔 it sounds like ppl r saying its all about mindset & expectations 😅 so if u think ur gonna be a hero then u prob will be 💪 but what about when reality hits hard & ur all "noooo"?!? 🤯 and wut's w/ the police/military ppl sayin fear is sensible tho 🤷‍♂️
 
🤔 idk lol. think ppl r wired 2 help others in crisis cuz its just human nature rn... but at the same time, fear is real & u gotta be honest w urself about how u feel about it... cant just pretend ur a hero if u dont believe it 🙅‍♂️... maybe its just bout finding that balance between courage & compassion?
 
i feel like people are really bad at putting themselves in other peoples shoes... imagine u r in a situation where ur trying to help & someone else is all "get outta here i got this" lol what if u try 2 go back & tell them they cant handle it? wouldnt that just make things worse 🤷‍♀️
 
😊 I was way too slow to chime in on this thread... anyway, it got me thinking - what if you're not even sure you'd be a hero in that situation? Like, what if your go-to response is actually just "get outta there"? 🤷‍♀️ Research says our brains are wired for community and social connection, so maybe we don't have to imagine ourselves as heroes before we act. Maybe it's just about showing up when people need help, you know? 💖
 
🤔 I feel like people tend to overthink this whole hero vs fear thing... sometimes it's just about instinct, you know? Like if you're literally trapped with no way out, you'll do whatever it takes to survive 💥 But when the danger's passed and you've got a moment to breathe, yeah, that's when the real hero stuff happens - not some grand, heroic act, but just plain ol' kindness to those affected 🤗
 
I think people tend to overthink this whole hero vs fear thing 🤔. I mean, what if you're just really scared for your own life? Does that make you a bad person? Newsflash: it's okay to prioritize yourself in a crisis! 😬 We need to stop putting so much pressure on ourselves to be heroes and start focusing on our own survival first. It's not about being a hero, it's about getting through the situation alive 💪. And after that, we can always try to help others later 🌎. The real question is, how do we support each other in those moments when fear takes over?
 
🤔 I'd rather just be present for those around me, even if it means helping in some small way, than try to force my own hero narrative 🌟💪. When fear kicks in, it's normal to want to prioritize myself, but that doesn't mean I have to ignore others' struggles entirely... just that I'd need time to gather my thoughts and respond in a way that feels authentic 👍💕
 
🌟 honestly, i think its super easy to imagine ourselves as heroes in theory, but when it comes down to it, our brains are just trying to keep us alive first. like, yeah sure, we might want to help others, but what if that means putting myself in harm's way? 🤔 for me, my experience and self-image play a huge role in how i'd react. if i've faced tough situations before and come out on top, id be more likely to take action. but if im someone who feels like they're just along for the ride most of the time, i probs wouldnt be brave enough to jump into the fray 🌊 also, its interesting that you mention hope for recovery and growth in post traumatic situations... ive seen it happen with friends and family members, and it's this crazy beautiful thing
 
I remember when I was younger and my friends were always like "oh man, if I saw someone drowning, I'd totally jump in to save 'em" lol like what? 🤣 nowadays i think its more about how you process your emotions & respond to situations. back then people would literally just freeze or freak out but now we know better (or so we tell ourselves) 😅 for me personally, i think its all about taking small steps towards helping others and being willing to learn from our mistakes.
 
You know what's crazy, I was just thinking about this the other day... have you ever noticed how some coffee shops have those cute little bird decorations on their windows? Like, it's always the same design, but they make it look so different each time 🐦💡. And it got me thinking, if I were to design my own coffee shop, what would be the theme? Maybe a mix of vintage and modern vibes, with a secret menu for when you're feeling extra adventurous... anyway, back to the news article... yeah, self-image and experience do play a huge role in how we react during emergencies. My grandma's always saying that practice makes perfect, maybe that's true! 🤔
 
idk man... thinkin bout this article makes me wanna freak out 😅. its like our brains r wired to respond 2 danger with both fight & flight modes at the same time - makes sense tho. but what if i said i'd never be able to handle it? that i'd just freeze up & run 🏃‍♂️? idk if thats a good thing or bad... think about people who r heroes in emergencies - do they always feel like heroes? and whats the diff b/w bein brave & just being decent human beings? can we even really choose between those 2 things?
 
🤔 I think it's all about mindset, you know? Like if you believe you can make a difference, you'll try to help others even when it's scary 🌟. And yeah, experience is super important too - the more times you're in a tough spot, the better you get at handling it 😅. But for me, it's not just about what you do, but also why you do it 💖. If you genuinely care about helping others and being a positive force in the world, that's when things start to click 🔗.

It's weird, because sometimes I think we're more scared of not trying than we are of actually facing danger 😬. Like, what if we just stay out of it? 🤷‍♀️ But then you have those people who, like, literally put themselves in harm's way for others... and that's just amazing 💪.

I mean, it's not an easy question to answer, but I think it's all about finding that balance between being brave and being smart 🤔. And honestly, even if we can't be heroes all the time, every little bit counts, right? Even just knowing someone's in danger and trying to reach out or help in some way... that makes a difference ❤️.

So yeah, I guess what I'm saying is, it's all about being true to yourself and finding your own way of making a positive impact 🌈. And who knows, you might be surprised at how much courage you have within you 💪!
 
🤔 "The greatest glory in living lies not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall." 💪 We all have the capacity to rise above fear and uncertainty, but it's how our brains are wired that matters. Our social connections and community ties can be a powerful motivator to help others, while fear can also take over in emergency situations. But what if we could tap into that inner hero within? 🌟
 
I've had that feeling before 🤯 when I was stuck in a situation with no clear escape route. My mind just freezes and my body goes into "fight or flight" mode 😂. But the funny thing is, I'd always imagine myself being the hero who saves others... until I actually put myself in that spot 💪. Then I'm like everyone else - terrified 🤕. It's crazy how our brains can play tricks on us like that.

I also think about those emergency responders, like police and firefighters, who are trained to deal with these situations all the time 🔥. They're not just heroes by default; they've actually worked hard to develop the skills and mindset needed to stay calm under pressure 💪. I mean, can you imagine being able to separate your emotions from your decision-making process that quickly? 🤯 That's like a superpower in itself!
 
idk man... thinkin bout this and i gotta say... i feel bad 4 people who are too scared to act when they should be helpin others 🤔. like, dont get me wrong, fear is real and all that but i think we can train ourselves 2 be braver than dat 💪. and its not just about bein a hero or a zero, its about takin responsibility 4 our own lives and makin a positive impact wherever we go 🌎. personally, id rather take a chance and try 2 help someone in need than just run away 👍. but at the same time, i get it... emergencies r crazy and u gotta prioritize urself sometimes 💔. anywayz, thinkin bout all this makes me wanna learn more about psychology & how our brains work 📚👀
 
Omg I'm literally thinking about this right now 🤔 I know it's easy to imagine ourselves as heroes in those situations, but honestly who hasn't frozen up at some point when things got real scary 😱? It's so interesting how our brains are wired for social connection & community too! 🤝 For me, if I'm being completely honest, I think my willingness to help others would depend on like a million factors - does the situation feel super urgent? do I know someone involved? am I in a safe space? etc. 😊 But what's so cool is that it sounds like research shows that our self-image & experience play such a huge role! 🤓
 
Back
Top