Google's Latest Attempt to Justify Expensive Smart Home Security Camera Subscriptions: A Review of the Google Nest Doorbell Cam
As AI becomes increasingly prominent in smart home security cameras, Google is betting that its sophisticated technology will justify the hefty price tags associated with its subscription-based cloud storage services. The idea is simple: with AI-powered notifications and daily summaries, homeowners can effortlessly stay on top of their security without constantly sifting through hours of footage.
Unfortunately, this promise rings hollow for many users. In our review of the Google Nest Doorbell Cam (wired, 3rd gen), we found that AI-generated descriptions are often riddled with inaccuracies, misidentifying pets and animals as well as providing vague summaries of events triggered by motion detection.
For instance, in one test scenario, the AI described my cat as a dog - no matter how many times I corrected it. Similarly, daily summaries often made it sound like my house was experiencing an influx of visitors or that there were multiple people at my door when, in reality, it was just my family members going about their day.
Given these limitations, it's hard to see why the Nest Doorbell would be a worthwhile purchase for those not deeply invested in the Google Home ecosystem. The camera offers solid specs, including a wide-angle view and fast Wi-Fi connectivity, but its AI-powered features are underwhelming at best.
That being said, if you're already entrenched in the Google Home world and plan to use your Nest Doorbell as part of a comprehensive smart home setup, this device might still be a good choice. The integration with other Google products is seamless, making it easy to connect the doorbell to your Google Home app or smart speakers.
Ultimately, however, the $20/month Google Home Premium subscription fee for AI-powered features like daily summaries and notifications feels excessive, especially when compared to cheaper alternative video doorbells that offer local storage. In our review of the Reolink Elite, we found that similar AI search capabilities were available without a subscription.
For those not deeply invested in Google's ecosystem or looking to save money on their smart home setup, there are better options available. The Nest Doorbell is good enough if you're all-in on Google Home, but its limitations and high price make it hard to recommend for anyone else.
As AI becomes increasingly prominent in smart home security cameras, Google is betting that its sophisticated technology will justify the hefty price tags associated with its subscription-based cloud storage services. The idea is simple: with AI-powered notifications and daily summaries, homeowners can effortlessly stay on top of their security without constantly sifting through hours of footage.
Unfortunately, this promise rings hollow for many users. In our review of the Google Nest Doorbell Cam (wired, 3rd gen), we found that AI-generated descriptions are often riddled with inaccuracies, misidentifying pets and animals as well as providing vague summaries of events triggered by motion detection.
For instance, in one test scenario, the AI described my cat as a dog - no matter how many times I corrected it. Similarly, daily summaries often made it sound like my house was experiencing an influx of visitors or that there were multiple people at my door when, in reality, it was just my family members going about their day.
Given these limitations, it's hard to see why the Nest Doorbell would be a worthwhile purchase for those not deeply invested in the Google Home ecosystem. The camera offers solid specs, including a wide-angle view and fast Wi-Fi connectivity, but its AI-powered features are underwhelming at best.
That being said, if you're already entrenched in the Google Home world and plan to use your Nest Doorbell as part of a comprehensive smart home setup, this device might still be a good choice. The integration with other Google products is seamless, making it easy to connect the doorbell to your Google Home app or smart speakers.
Ultimately, however, the $20/month Google Home Premium subscription fee for AI-powered features like daily summaries and notifications feels excessive, especially when compared to cheaper alternative video doorbells that offer local storage. In our review of the Reolink Elite, we found that similar AI search capabilities were available without a subscription.
For those not deeply invested in Google's ecosystem or looking to save money on their smart home setup, there are better options available. The Nest Doorbell is good enough if you're all-in on Google Home, but its limitations and high price make it hard to recommend for anyone else.