It's under fire from left and right – but Labour's workers' rights bill is a huge achievement | Polly Toynbee

Keir Starmer's government has made an unexpected breakthrough with Labour's workers' rights bill, which could have significant implications for the country. Despite being watered down in the House of Lords, the bill still represents a major achievement for the party and its supporters.

The bill, championed by Angela Rayner, aims to address long-standing issues affecting workers, including zero-hours contracts, unfair dismissal, and parental leave. One of the most significant changes is the introduction of day-one rights, which will protect workers from being unfairly dismissed within six months of starting a job – a far cry from the current two-year wait.

However, not everyone is celebrating this development. Sharon Graham, general secretary of Unite, has criticized the government for watering down key clauses in the bill, accusing them of "stealth tax" on workers. The union leader claims that the changes will make it difficult for Labour to win the trust of workers who have been left feeling betrayed.

The Trade Union Congress (TUC) acknowledges that some compromises were necessary, but argues that the bill still represents a significant step forward in protecting workers' rights. Christina McAnea, Unison's general secretary, notes that if the bill had not passed, it would have taken a year to bring about the same changes through parliament.

The Resolution Foundation has also expressed support for the watering down of certain clauses, citing concerns that day-one unfair dismissal could lead to an influx of tribunal cases and create difficulties for employers. However, this argument is disputed by many trade unions, including Unison, which argues that workers should have greater protections against unfair treatment.

One of the most significant implications of the bill is its potential impact on the rise of union membership. With the introduction of fair pay agreements in key sectors like care work and the expansion of parental leave rights, it's likely that more people will begin to join unions and demand better working conditions.

The reactions from business leaders and media outlets are telling. While some have praised the government for its efforts, others have attacked Labour for "plotting" against businesses. However, the public seems to be with the party on this issue. A recent poll found that 72% of workers want zero-hours contracts replaced with firm contracts.

As the debate around the bill continues, it's clear that there are different perspectives on what constitutes a "good deal" for workers and employers alike. But one thing is certain – Labour's workers' rights bill represents a major cultural shift in the country's approach to employment law, and its impact will be felt for years to come.

The legacy of this government will likely be determined by how they manage these reforms, particularly in relation to unionization and worker rights. As Nigel Farage's voters have shown, many are open to changing their views on issues like immigration and reforming the welfare state. However, when it comes to workers' rights, Farage himself and his MPs voted against key measures in the bill.

It remains to be seen whether Labour can build on this momentum and push through further reforms that address the needs of low-paid workers and those struggling to make ends meet. But for now, the passage of the workers' rights bill is a significant victory for the party and its supporters – one that could mark the beginning of a new era in employment law.
 
🌟 This breakthrough on the Labour's workers' rights bill is a huge deal, fam! I'm loving how it shows that even when there's compromise, progress can still be made. Day-one rights are literally a game-changer for workers and it's amazing to see the public supporting this move - 72% of people want zero-hours contracts gone? That's some serious momentum! 😊 The fact that trade unions like Unison are pushing back against the watering down of clauses shows that workers aren't going to let their rights be compromised. This is a major cultural shift and I'm excited to see where it takes us. 💪
 
I'm low-key disappointed they didn't water it down more 🤔. I mean, we're still stuck with day-one rights and parental leave being limited to certain sectors. It's like, what's the point of having a bill if you can just go back on most of the promises? 💸 And don't even get me started on the "stealth tax" thing – it sounds like a load of nonsense to me 😒. I'm all for making it easier for businesses to hire and fire people, as long as they're not being completely screwed over in the process 🤑.
 
🤔 I'm not sure if Labour's compromise on the bill was enough... Some people might see it as a step forward, while others think it's just a watered-down version 🤷‍♂️. What really matters is that workers' rights are being addressed and more people are starting to care about fair pay and parental leave 🚀. Still, the fact that Sharon Graham from Unite called out the government for "stealth tax" on workers tells me that there's still a lot of work to be done 💼
 
I'm shocked, SHOCKED, that some people still think Labour's watered-down bill is a total waste 🙄. I mean, come on, Sharon Graham's "stealth tax" claims are pretty rich considering her own party's history with union-busting 💁‍♀️. It's all about finding common ground and compromises, right? 😒 The Resolution Foundation's concerns about tribunal cases just seem like a convenient excuse to delay progress 🕰️. And let's be real, the public is already on Labour's side when it comes to zero-hours contracts – who doesn't want more job security and fair pay? 💸
 
I'm kinda loving this news 🤩! I mean, it's not perfect, but Labour's got some real momentum on their side right now. Those day-one rights? Game changer 😊. I get what Sharon Graham and Unite are saying about the "stealth tax" on workers, but at least we're seeing some actual change happening 🔄. And let's be real, 72% of workers want zero-hours contracts gone - that's a clear message from the people 🗣️! The fact that some business leaders are whining about it just shows they're out of touch with reality 😂. This bill might not be a panacea, but it's a step in the right direction towards creating a more fair and equal society 💪. Bring on the unionization efforts and let's get those workers' rights protected 🎉!
 
[A picture of a person holding a " Workers Unite" sign with a red circle around it] 🤬👥

[An image of Angela Rayner smiling, with a green checkmark over her head] 🌿💚

[GIF of Keir Starmer giving a thumbs up with a bright background] 👍💪
 
🤬 so yeah this bill is kinda big deal, i mean it's not perfect but it's better than nothing. i'm all about workers rights, it's about time someone actually listened to the people who do all the work and makes the money. 😒 i hate zero-hours contracts, that's just nasty stuff. having day-one rights is a huge step forward, no more being unfairly kicked out after six months of trying your best. 👊

i'm not surprised some business leaders are whining about it though, they're always looking for ways to screw their workers and make a profit off them. 🤑 but the public is on our side, 72% want those zero-hours contracts gone. that's what matters, not what the rich folks think.

and yeah, this might be the start of something big, labour might actually do some good for once. 💪 it's about time they represented the people and not just the fat cats in suits.
 
U r kidding me 🤯! Sharon Graham thinks Labour did us dirty by watering down the bill? Like, what did she expect? The gov's all about compromise. Day-one rights? Who wouldn't want that? 🙌 I'm just glad they're finally taking workers' rights seriously. Unison's got a point tho, employers need to stop playing games with people's livelihoods 🤑

Poll says 72% of workers wanna ditch zero-hours contracts? That's a no-brainer, fam! 💪 The gov's on the right track here. It's about time we give workers some real power and security. Can't wait to see what other changes they make next 🔥
 
I don’t usually comment but I think this whole thing about Labour's workers’ rights bill being watered down is a bit weird 🤔. I mean, sure, some people are saying it’s not perfect and that it’s going to lead to more tribunal cases, but like, isn’t the point of having a bill that it’s better than nothing? 🙄 And 72% of workers wanting zero-hours contracts replaced with firm contracts is pretty telling 💪. It feels like there's still a lot of resistance from businesses and politicians to actually making real change happen 👎. I guess we'll just have to wait and see how this all plays out in the end 🤞.
 
I think it's a total bust 🤦‍♂️. This bill might seem like a win for Labour, but trust me, it's just a watered-down version that'll never make a real difference. They're just appeasing the unions and special interest groups to get some brownie points. Newsflash: it won't actually help workers or create more union members - those people are smart enough to know what's good for them already 💁‍♀️. And as for business leaders, they're just mad because their precious profits might be affected by actual fairness and decency in the workplace 🤑. The only ones who'll benefit from this bill are Labour politicians trying to get re-elected - not the regular Joe who's actually struggling to make ends meet 😒.
 
🤝🏼💪🏽 big win for labour 🙌🏽! 👍🏽 they finally did something about those nasty zero-hours contracts 😒👎. 72% of workers want change 📊, and now they're getting it 💥! 🚀 but lets be real, some of the changes were watered down 🤦‍♂️😔. still, its a major step forward for workers' rights 👉💼👍
 
Back
Top