New York City May Face Crisis of Unlivable Apartments After International Firm Buys Rent-Stabilized Complex
A federal bankruptcy judge on Friday finalized a highly contentious sale of over 5,100 rent-stabilized apartments to an international real estate firm. The deal has sent shockwaves through the city's housing market and is seen as a major setback for Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who campaigned on a platform of cracking down on negligent landlords.
The company, Summit Properties USA, purchased the 93-building portfolio from Pinnacle Group, which filed for bankruptcy last May. The sale price was $451 million, with Pinnacle's lender, Flagstar, providing financial backing. Critics argue that the deal prioritizes profits over tenant safety and ignores a long history of maintenance neglect.
Judge David Jones approved the deal after Summit Properties USA outlined a plan to address nearly 6,500 outstanding housing code violations in Pinnacle's portfolio. The company promised to spend $30 million on repairs and maintenance over the next five years, with an initial focus on resolving half of the issues within two months. However, tenants and city officials remain skeptical about the firm's ability to manage the properties and address concerns about open housing code violations.
Residents in many Pinnacle buildings have documented a history of crumbling conditions, including blood-stained kitchens, maggot-infested refrigerators, and burst steam pipes. Tenants' groups say they will continue to organize and fight for better living conditions, citing Mayor Mamdani's efforts as an important step forward in holding landlords accountable.
The sale is seen as a major blow to Mayor Mamdani's efforts to protect tenants, who have faced years of neglect and harassment from Pinnacle's previous owner. The city's involvement in the sale process raised concerns about the firm's financial backing and its ability to manage the properties responsibly.
Despite these concerns, Summit Properties USA maintains that it has the "financial wherewithal" to run the portfolio properly and make necessary repairs. The company's chairman, Zohar Levy, claimed that his company is committed to addressing the issues and improving living conditions in the buildings. However, many tenants remain skeptical, citing a history of neglect and a lack of transparency from Pinnacle and its successor firm.
The deal marks a significant shift in the city's housing market, as Summit Properties USA becomes one of New York City's largest owners of rent-stabilized apartments. The implications for tenants are uncertain, with some fearing that conditions will deteriorate further under new management.
A federal bankruptcy judge on Friday finalized a highly contentious sale of over 5,100 rent-stabilized apartments to an international real estate firm. The deal has sent shockwaves through the city's housing market and is seen as a major setback for Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who campaigned on a platform of cracking down on negligent landlords.
The company, Summit Properties USA, purchased the 93-building portfolio from Pinnacle Group, which filed for bankruptcy last May. The sale price was $451 million, with Pinnacle's lender, Flagstar, providing financial backing. Critics argue that the deal prioritizes profits over tenant safety and ignores a long history of maintenance neglect.
Judge David Jones approved the deal after Summit Properties USA outlined a plan to address nearly 6,500 outstanding housing code violations in Pinnacle's portfolio. The company promised to spend $30 million on repairs and maintenance over the next five years, with an initial focus on resolving half of the issues within two months. However, tenants and city officials remain skeptical about the firm's ability to manage the properties and address concerns about open housing code violations.
Residents in many Pinnacle buildings have documented a history of crumbling conditions, including blood-stained kitchens, maggot-infested refrigerators, and burst steam pipes. Tenants' groups say they will continue to organize and fight for better living conditions, citing Mayor Mamdani's efforts as an important step forward in holding landlords accountable.
The sale is seen as a major blow to Mayor Mamdani's efforts to protect tenants, who have faced years of neglect and harassment from Pinnacle's previous owner. The city's involvement in the sale process raised concerns about the firm's financial backing and its ability to manage the properties responsibly.
Despite these concerns, Summit Properties USA maintains that it has the "financial wherewithal" to run the portfolio properly and make necessary repairs. The company's chairman, Zohar Levy, claimed that his company is committed to addressing the issues and improving living conditions in the buildings. However, many tenants remain skeptical, citing a history of neglect and a lack of transparency from Pinnacle and its successor firm.
The deal marks a significant shift in the city's housing market, as Summit Properties USA becomes one of New York City's largest owners of rent-stabilized apartments. The implications for tenants are uncertain, with some fearing that conditions will deteriorate further under new management.
... it doesn't sound good at all if the firm can only fix half of the issues within two months 
. Like, how's that gonna help? And what's with the $30 million for repairs and maintenance over five years? That's just a drop in the bucket compared to what these buildings need 
... I mean, have you seen those pics of blood-stained kitchens and maggot-infested fridges? Gross! 
They claim to have the "financial wherewithal" to run it properly, but I'm not convinced 
... and why didn't Pinnacle Group just sell the properties themselves instead of going through all this drama? 
...
and whats up with the $30 million promise tho like how does that even work 
. And what really gets me is that Mayor Mamdani was trying to do something about this problem but now it seems like everything he said was for nothing 
. The city needs to step up its game and hold these corporations accountable for their actions. We need more affordable housing, not just empty promises from the mayor's office 
.
.
... but tenants are still gonna organize and fight for better living conditions, which is good, i guess 
. maybe summit properties usa will surprise us all and do the right thing? 
but honestly, i'm still skeptical 
.
this is so not good! I mean, think about it - a super big company like Summit Properties USA just buys up all these rent-stabilized apartments and then says they're gonna fix everything? 
Anyway, Mayor Mamdani was on the right track with his efforts to crack down on negligent landlords, but now it looks like he's lost control of the situation. I'm so worried about all these people living in basically uninhabitable conditions... what are they gonna do? 
, but it dont sit right wit me... Summit Properties USA buyin all dem rent-stabilized units 4 cheap? that's like gettin a sweet deal, but wen u dig deeper, its just gonna benefit dem profiteers 
. Time 4 tenant rights 2 be taken seriously, not just a pretty face