A man who was acquitted of a murder-for-hire plot aimed at US Border Patrol Cmdr. Gregory Bovino is now facing deportation after being taken into ICE custody.
Juan Espinoza Martinez, 37, was arrested by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Friday morning, just hours after he was found not guilty of the crime. His lawyers had argued that the government's case relied heavily on circumstantial evidence and social media messages that were misinterpreted or taken out of context.
The acquittal was a major victory for Espinoza Martinez's attorneys, Jonathan Bedi and Dena Singer, who claimed that the jury system worked as intended to protect an innocent man from political persecution. However, ICE officials say that the verdict does not change the facts: Espinoza targeted federal law enforcement with violence via Snapchat.
Espinoza Martinez has lived in Chicago for 30 years, has three children and a reputation in his community built over the past decade working on his brother's construction company. His attorneys argue that he is an innocent man whose entire existence is rooted in this district, with no passport or property outside of Illinois.
The government had originally accused Espinoza Martinez of being a high-ranking member of the Latin Kings gang, but prosecutors did not prove this at trial. Instead, they relied on messages exchanged between Espinoza and his brother that suggested he was planning to harm Bovino.
However, Espinoza's lawyers argued that these messages were misinterpreted or taken out of context, and that there was no concrete evidence to support the government's claims. In their own statement, Bedi and Singer claimed that the government had failed to prove its case, saying "the crime here was complete the moment he sent those words."
Despite his acquittal, Espinoza Martinez now faces deportation due to his immigration status. His attorneys have expressed concerns about the fairness of the process, with Bedi stating that the verdict shows the power of the jury system in protecting innocent people from overreaching government agencies.
Juan Espinoza Martinez, 37, was arrested by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Friday morning, just hours after he was found not guilty of the crime. His lawyers had argued that the government's case relied heavily on circumstantial evidence and social media messages that were misinterpreted or taken out of context.
The acquittal was a major victory for Espinoza Martinez's attorneys, Jonathan Bedi and Dena Singer, who claimed that the jury system worked as intended to protect an innocent man from political persecution. However, ICE officials say that the verdict does not change the facts: Espinoza targeted federal law enforcement with violence via Snapchat.
Espinoza Martinez has lived in Chicago for 30 years, has three children and a reputation in his community built over the past decade working on his brother's construction company. His attorneys argue that he is an innocent man whose entire existence is rooted in this district, with no passport or property outside of Illinois.
The government had originally accused Espinoza Martinez of being a high-ranking member of the Latin Kings gang, but prosecutors did not prove this at trial. Instead, they relied on messages exchanged between Espinoza and his brother that suggested he was planning to harm Bovino.
However, Espinoza's lawyers argued that these messages were misinterpreted or taken out of context, and that there was no concrete evidence to support the government's claims. In their own statement, Bedi and Singer claimed that the government had failed to prove its case, saying "the crime here was complete the moment he sent those words."
Despite his acquittal, Espinoza Martinez now faces deportation due to his immigration status. His attorneys have expressed concerns about the fairness of the process, with Bedi stating that the verdict shows the power of the jury system in protecting innocent people from overreaching government agencies.
This is such a bummer for Juan Espinoza Martinez, I mean, he was acquitted and all, but now he's facing deportation? It's just not fair 
. He's been living in Chicago for 30 years, got three kids, built a reputation in his community... what's the US government gonna do to him next? 
.
. Anyway, I hope Juan gets some sort of deal or something, 'cause deporting him just ain't right 
It feels like his whole life and reputation are being thrown out the window because of some misinterpreted messages. And what about all the other stuff they didn't prove at trial? Does that count for anything?
ICE's decision to deport Espinoza Martinez after his acquittal raises questions about the fairness of the immigration system. The fact that he was found not guilty by a jury doesn't necessarily mean he committed the crime, but does it matter if he's an innocent man with roots in this community? His reputation and family are at stake here. Is deportation really the right punishment for someone who is fighting to stay in the only country they've ever called home? 
ICE is super harsh here 
I mean what's the point of having a jury system if it just lets people off scot free for serious crimes then picks them up again when they're in trouble with immigration 
And what about his community reputation over the past decade? Doesn't that give him some kind of credibility? I'm not saying he was innocent, but it seems like there were some major missteps in the case against him. Did the government just assume he'd be guilty because of his background with the Latin Kings gang? 
What's the point of having a border if you're just gonna deport someone for a message sent 10 years ago?
. I mean, he's been living in Chicago for 30 years, built a whole life here, and now this? It's like one mistake on Snapchat changes everything... I don't get it. His lawyers are right, the jury did protect him from a miscarriage of justice, but what about his future here? He's got three kids, just trying to live a good life. And now ICE is taking him away? 
.
? how does that even work? he's been living in chicago for 30 yrs, got a rep in the community and three kids 
... it doesn't seem like he'd be wanted anywhere else. did they really think his immigration status would change just cuz he was acquitted of murder-for-hire? 
is it just a case of them being too harsh or what's the real deal here? 
Anyway, I'm all for the jury system and its power to protect innocent people, but in this case, it feels like the gov't is just trying to exploit his immigration status. 
Can't they just leave him alone after the acquittal? 
it's just not fair, u feel?
anyway, I do think it's crazy how ICE is making this move against him without fully considering the bigger picture. 