NFL's annual Team Report Cards sparks labor law controversy.
The National Football League Players Association (NFLPA) has been releasing its Team Report Cards since 2023, grading the 32 NFL clubs on their treatment of families, food, support staff, travel, training facilities, coaches, and ownership. The report cards have sparked outrage among teams that received poor grades, with some expressing their displeasure directly to the NFL.
However, the league has taken issue with the report cards, arguing that they violate a provision in the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) that prohibits public comments by club personnel or players that express criticism of any other person involved in the operation of the team. The NFL claims that the report cards are an obvious expression of players' rights under Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), which protects employees from interference with their right to engage in concerted activity.
The NLRA has been instrumental in protecting workers' rights since its passage in 1935, allowing employees to unionize and requiring employers to bargain in good faith on wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment. The Supreme Court has also interpreted Section 7 as a broad right that enables employees to communicate freely with each other about workplace issues.
In the NFL's case, the league argues that the CBA provision was intended as a waiver of players' rights under the NLRA. However, experts say it is highly questionable whether this provision is meant to be a clear waiver. The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) has taken expansive views on Section 7 protections in recent years, and some employer policies have raised concerns.
The NFL's request for an expedited hearing before the next report cards are issued in February 2026 highlights the ongoing controversy over the matter. As one arbitrator is likely to decide, the issue may not be resolved until then.
The National Football League Players Association (NFLPA) has been releasing its Team Report Cards since 2023, grading the 32 NFL clubs on their treatment of families, food, support staff, travel, training facilities, coaches, and ownership. The report cards have sparked outrage among teams that received poor grades, with some expressing their displeasure directly to the NFL.
However, the league has taken issue with the report cards, arguing that they violate a provision in the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) that prohibits public comments by club personnel or players that express criticism of any other person involved in the operation of the team. The NFL claims that the report cards are an obvious expression of players' rights under Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), which protects employees from interference with their right to engage in concerted activity.
The NLRA has been instrumental in protecting workers' rights since its passage in 1935, allowing employees to unionize and requiring employers to bargain in good faith on wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment. The Supreme Court has also interpreted Section 7 as a broad right that enables employees to communicate freely with each other about workplace issues.
In the NFL's case, the league argues that the CBA provision was intended as a waiver of players' rights under the NLRA. However, experts say it is highly questionable whether this provision is meant to be a clear waiver. The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) has taken expansive views on Section 7 protections in recent years, and some employer policies have raised concerns.
The NFL's request for an expedited hearing before the next report cards are issued in February 2026 highlights the ongoing controversy over the matter. As one arbitrator is likely to decide, the issue may not be resolved until then.
... like when they lock players out for a year and call it a "work stoppage" 
... can't believe the league is getting all bent out of shape over some report cards 
, like it's a federal law or something 
... and what's with this "waiver" business? are they trying to make us believe that's not just a fancy word for "we don't want you talking about us"? 
... anyway, I guess we'll just have to wait and see how the arbitrator rules out on it 
. And honestly, it's hard to blame the players for speaking out - if they're not getting paid or treated fairly, that's gotta count for something 
.
. The NFL's tryin' to silence their players and limit their ability to speak out about working conditions? It sounds like a classic case of cover-up 
. I mean, what's really goin' on here? Are they hidin' somethin'? Maybe there's some shady stuff goin' down behind the scenes that they don't want exposed 
. This whole thing's got me thinkin' there's some big money involved somewhere... maybe in the form of a massive settlement or somethin'? 
.
I mean, can you believe these teams are getting graded like they're in school? Team Report Cards, huh? Sounds like my college profs were trying to give us a reality check on our partying ways 
. But seriously, it's all about who's right – the players or the league. Maybe we should just start calling them 'Team Parental Guidance' instead of Report Cards 
. Anyways, I'm rooting for the players – they're speaking truth to power and all that jazz 
. Who knows how long it'll take before the issue gets settled? Maybe in February 2026, we'll have an answer and can finally get back to what really matters: the game! 
. Like, if someone's being a jerk to you at work, shouldn't you be able to say something about it? I mean, the report cards are meant to help teams improve, not keep them quiet 
.
. I think it's just a case of the league trying to silence players and teams from speaking up, which isn't cool 
.
. If the NFL can get away with using this provision to stifle criticism, what other employers might do it too? That would be super sketchy 
.