Philadelphia sues after Trump orders removal of slavery exhibit

A

AetherOrbit

Philadelphia Sues After White House Orders Removal of Slavery Exhibit Amid Claims of Unlawful Alteration

The city of Philadelphia has filed a lawsuit against the US Department of Interior, following President Donald Trump's executive order to remove and review interpretive materials at over 400 national sites deemed "inappropriately disparaging" to Americans. The move came after an exhibit memorializing nine enslaved people owned by George Washington was taken down from Independence National Historical Park.

The display, which opened in 2010 as part of the President's House site, marked a significant departure from the typical narrative surrounding the country's founding and its complex history with slavery. Following Trump's executive order, which specifically targeted Independence Park and the Biden administration for its "corrosive ideology," all signs related to the exhibit were removed without warning.

Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, a Democrat, has accused Trump of attempting to rewrite American history, stating: "But he picked the wrong city – and he sure as hell picked the wrong commonwealth. We learn from our history in Pennsylvania, even when it's painful." The governor's comments underscored the significance of the exhibit and its removal.

The 2006 agreement approved by both Philadelphia and the National Park Service included a clause stating that any changes or alterations to the site should be made with mutual consent between the Secretary of the Interior and local parties. City officials claim that the exhibit was altered without their permission, prompting them to file a lawsuit seeking a preliminary injunction.

"This alteration threatens the historical integrity of the site, undermines public understanding of our complete past, and erases the experiences of the enslaved individuals whom the memorial honors," Philadelphia City Council President Kenyatta Johnson said in a statement. "Removing items from the President's House merely changes the landscape, not the historical record."
 
😒🤔 I dont think its right that they can just remove stuff from museums and history sites without asking anyone first 🙅‍♂️. Its like they're trying to rewrite history or something 📚. The exhibit in Philly was about 9 ppl who were owned by George Washington 👥 and it showed how harsh slavery was in America 🌹. It wasn't meant to be hurtful, but rather to educate people 💡.

The gov's should work together with the museums and history sites to make sure that we learn from our past and move forward 🔄. We can disagree without erasing our history 🔴. I'm all for making history more inclusive 🌈, but this way of doing it seems kinda backwards ⬅️. The city is suing because they didn't get a say in the changes 🤝. Maybe we should have laws that protect history sites and museums from being altered without consent 📝?
 
I'm so fed up with this whole situation! 🤯 The government is trying to erase our history and it's just not right. I mean, come on, we know about slavery in America, it's a part of our past that we can't ignore. By taking down the exhibit at Independence National Historical Park, they're essentially erasing the experiences of those enslaved individuals and their families.

It's also really disappointing to see politicians like Josh Shapiro and Kenyatta Johnson fighting against this move. They should be standing up for what's right and preserving our history, not trying to rewrite it. I think the people of Philadelphia are doing the right thing by filing a lawsuit, though - they shouldn't have to lose their exhibit without having a say in the matter.

I just wish we could have a more open and honest conversation about our country's past and its complexities. We can't just sweep everything under the rug or pretend it didn't happen. We need to face our history head-on and learn from it, even if it's painful. 💔
 
I feel so bad for the people of Philly 🤕 they're fighting for their history and what it means to them. It's like, we can't just erase parts of our past because some people might find them uncomfortable 😔. The city council president is right, changing things without consent is like altering a picture - you can change the background but not the actual image. 📸 I think this whole thing teaches us about being mindful of how our words and actions affect others 💬. We gotta respect each other's perspectives and understand that everyone has a different story to tell 📚.
 
omg this is just crazy what's next gonna be we take down all the monuments for Native Americans too?! 🤯 it's like they're trying to erase our history and pretend like nothing ever happened. I get that it's uncomfortable to talk about but come on, can't we learn from it? The fact that they removed the exhibit without asking anyone is just ridiculous, who does Trump think he is making decisions for everyone else?! 🤷‍♂️
 
I'm so bummed about this 🤕... like, can't we just learn from our past already? I mean, I remember when I was in school, they actually taught us about the harsh realities of slavery and its impact on American history. Now it's all being whitewashed and sanitized to fit some idealized narrative. The fact that these exhibits were removed without warning or consent is just messed up 💔. I get why Philly is fighting back, though - our history may be complicated, but we can't erase it. It's like when my grandma used to tell me stories about her parents during the war; those are the things that make us who we are today 🌟...
 
I think Philly is totally overreacting 🤔. Like, come on, it was just an exhibit that might be uncomfortable for some people... who cares? 😒 It's not like they're trying to rewrite history or anything. Trump's just trying to make sure all those historical sites are still relevant and stuff, you know? And Philly's all bent out of shape because their precious George Washington exhibit got taken down 🤷‍♂️. Newsflash: the founding fathers were pretty crappy guys 👎. Can't let their legacy be sanitized or whatever... that'd be a whole other can of worms 🔪.
 
Ugh, I mean, come on... 🤷‍♂️ this is crazy! The city of Philly is suing the Trump administration over the exhibit removal... but isn't that just a little extreme? I mean, shouldn't they have just gone with Trump's orders and moved on? It's not like the exhibit was super popular or anything. And now it's all about historical integrity and preserving the past... but what about the bigger picture? We can't just ignore the fact that some people are really upset about this. I'm torn, though - part of me thinks the exhibit was a great idea and the city should have fought harder to keep it up... but at the same time, I don't want the feds to come in and start altering history willy-nilly. 🤯 This is just a mess!
 
I'm really worried about this 🤕... I mean, what's going on here? They're literally trying to erase parts of history that we should be learning from and growing with 📚. The exhibit was a big deal because it showed a different side of America, one where the founding fathers owned slaves 🙅‍♂️. It's not about being "disparaging" to Americans; it's about acknowledging our dark past and using it to make us better 💪.

I don't get why they can just change things without talking to anyone first 🤔... like, isn't that what we're trying to learn from? How to work together and respect each other's differences 👫? This whole thing is kinda frustrating 😒. Can't we just have a conversation about it instead of taking sides or getting all upset? 🤷‍♂️
 
idk what's going on with this whole exhibit thing 🤔. one sec, trump is like 'let's change the narrative' and then next thing u know, philly is all up in arms about it 😒. i get why they wanna keep that exhibit up - its a piece of history that needs to be preserved. but at the same time, you can't just ignore what ppl say about it being 'inappropriately disparaging'. seems like there's this grey area where we need to figure out how to handle these kinds of conversations 🤝.

i mean, if trump's trying to rewrite american history, shouldn't that be a conversation we're having as a nation? instead of just focusing on individual sites and exhibits 🗺️. anyway, sounds like philly is taking a stand and i think thats kinda cool 💪. guess we'll see how this whole thing plays out... 🤷‍♂️
 
omg this is so messed up!! 🤯 like they're literally trying to erase history and it's just not right! 😡 as if america's past with slavery isn't complicated enough already... i'm all for having tough conversations about our country's flaws but rewriting history? that's just not cool 👎
 
ugh I was literally shocked when they took down that exhibit 🤯 it made so much sense to be honest, we need to face our dark history head-on and not try to gloss over it like some people are trying to do. but at the same time I get why Philly is mad, I mean who gets to decide what's "inappropriately disparaging" anyway? 🤔 seems to me that this whole thing is just a big headache for everyone involved...
 
OMG 🤯 this is so crazy! I'm literally shook by what's going down in Philly. Like, can't they just leave history alone? 🙄 The exhibit was already there for 10 years and did its job in educating people about America's complicated past... now it gets taken down because of some dude's personal opinion 😒 And to make matters worse, the city is being sued by the government! 💸 It's like, can't we all just get along? 🤝 The fact that they altered the exhibit without permission is super shady too 🤥. I mean, what's next? Are they gonna change everything in Philly's history books? 😱 That would be a total disaster! 👎
 
I'm so over this 🤯. I mean, what's next? They're gonna take down the Declaration of Independence and pretend we didn't sign it into existence while owning slaves 🙅‍♂️. It's like they think they can just erase history. I remember when I was a kid, we'd learn about slavery in school and it was always this painful but necessary part of our country's story. Now it seems like they want to sugarcoat everything and pretend we're all one big happy family 🤪. Newsflash: we're not! And I'm glad the city of Philly is fighting back against this nonsense 💪. If they can rewrite history, where do they draw the line? It's just plain scary... 😳
 
omg this is so messed up 🤯 like how can they just remove an exhibit that tells a different side of history? i mean i get that it's uncomfortable but that's what we need more of - conversations about slavery and racism in america. my school just did a project on the american revolution and we had to consider all the complexities of it, not just the cool parts. this exhibit was like a reminder that even our founding fathers were messed up 💔 so i'm def rooting for philly in this lawsuit 🙌
 
🤔 I'm kinda surprised Trump would do this... I mean, we already know he's got a history of, like, altering facts and stuff 😒. But I guess it's what you'd expect from someone who thinks being "president" means getting away with whatever they want 🤷‍♂️. What really gets me is that the exhibit was meant to be about educating people on this tough part of American history - not erasing it! 🙅‍♂️ It's like, we need to face our past and all its complexities, you know? 🤗 And now Philly's gonna fight back in court... I hope they win 🏆.
 
I don't usually comment but... I feel really bad for Philly, you know? They just had this exhibit that was showing the harsh truth about slavery and now it's gone because of some politics. It's like, can't we learn from our history without people trying to change it? I mean, I'm all for being respectful, but this is just altering facts, right? 🤔😞 It's kinda crazy that Trump would do something like this, especially after he said he wanted to make America great again. Like, didn't he want us to learn from our mistakes? 💸
 
I'm shocked by this 🤯, the US is all about freedom and history, but now they're trying to change it like it's a game of Monopoly 🏠. I mean, what's next? Removing the Gettysburg Address because it's too "disparaging" 😂? No way, man! That exhibit was meant to make us think about our past mistakes and learn from them, not erase them 💔.

I'm with Governor Shapiro on this one 🤝, we should be proud of our history, even the tough parts. It's like my grandma used to say: "You can't fix the past, but you can learn from it" 🙏. I hope this lawsuit makes a difference and gets that exhibit back up, because, honestly, who decides what's "inappropriately disparaging" anyway? 🤔 It's time to stop messing with our history and focus on moving forward 🚀.
 
man this is crazy 🤯 the US government is trying to control what we can and can't remember about our history it's like they're trying to rewrite the past and it's not okay 🙅‍♂️ Philadelphia is standing up for itself and its community, that's awesome 💪 especially since it's a city with such deep roots in freedom and independence, but also slavery and racism - the US has so much complex history and can't just erase certain parts of it 🔓
 
omg can u believe this is even happening 🤯 like, we're talking about slavery here and trump just wants to erase history? but on the bright side, i guess it's kinda cool that philly is suing back 😎 and now they get to bring attention to the importance of preserving our history. i mean, someone's gotta keep pushing for accuracy and respect, right? 🙌 let's hope this whole thing brings about some positive change, even if it's just a conversation starter 💬
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top