Israel's Oscar Entry 'The Sea' Brings a Humanizing Gaze to the Occupation
In "The Sea," director-writer Shai Carmeli Pollak offers a poignant portrayal of life under occupation, weaving a narrative that's both deeply personal and socially charged. The film tells the story of Khaled, a 12-year-old boy from a Palestinian village in the occupied West Bank who embarks on a perilous journey to see the sea – an experience reserved for those living in Israel.
Pollak's lens captures the complexities of life under occupation with remarkable nuance, revealing the intricate dance between economic necessity and cultural repression. The film is set against the backdrop of Tel Aviv's urban "bubble," where the privileges and disconnects of a privileged class are starkly juxtaposed against the harsh realities faced by Palestinians.
At its core, "The Sea" is a story about borders, permits, and the power of language – specifically Hebrew, which Khaled struggles to learn. This theme serves as a powerful metaphor for the exclusionary policies that govern Palestinian life under occupation. The film's portrayal of these tensions is both unsentimental and deeply empathetic.
One of the standout performances comes from Mohammed Ghazaoui, who wins an award with his nearly silent portrayal of Khaled. His character's presence is marked by a quiet desperation, as he navigates a world where freedom to move and experience is curtailed at every turn.
Khalifa Natour delivers a similarly nuanced performance as Ribhi, Khaled's father, whose struggles are exacerbated by the occupation. Every phone call in Arabic is a gamble, as he faces suspicion from those around him. The tension builds as Ribhi sets out to find his son, facing the risks of being caught and deported.
The film's climax, which takes place in a bustling Tel Aviv café, serves as a powerful commentary on empathy and understanding. While some may interpret this finale as sentimental or manipulative, it feels instead like a nuanced exploration of human connection in the face of adversity.
Overall, "The Sea" is a moving tribute to the resilience and humanity of Palestinian youth under occupation. Pollak's direction masterfully balances the personal story of Khaled with the broader social context, offering a powerful critique of Israel's policies without resorting to simplistic solutions or polemic.
Shot in a straightforward style with an acute attention to detail, the film is elevated by its thoughtful collaboration between Jewish and Palestinian Israeli creatives. This genuine partnership not only lends authenticity to the story but also underscores the shared humanity at its core. By centering the voices of Palestinians, "The Sea" offers a vital contribution to the ongoing conversation about Israel's occupation – one that demands to be heard.
In an era where narratives often reinforce binary oppositions, Pollak's film is a rare gift: a deeply humanizing gaze that shows us the world through the eyes of those most affected by our policies. "The Sea" may not offer easy solutions or comforting platitudes; it instead invites us to confront the complexities and tensions at the heart of this conflict – and perhaps, just perhaps, to see ourselves in Khaled's quiet determination to experience life beyond his village's borders.
In "The Sea," director-writer Shai Carmeli Pollak offers a poignant portrayal of life under occupation, weaving a narrative that's both deeply personal and socially charged. The film tells the story of Khaled, a 12-year-old boy from a Palestinian village in the occupied West Bank who embarks on a perilous journey to see the sea – an experience reserved for those living in Israel.
Pollak's lens captures the complexities of life under occupation with remarkable nuance, revealing the intricate dance between economic necessity and cultural repression. The film is set against the backdrop of Tel Aviv's urban "bubble," where the privileges and disconnects of a privileged class are starkly juxtaposed against the harsh realities faced by Palestinians.
At its core, "The Sea" is a story about borders, permits, and the power of language – specifically Hebrew, which Khaled struggles to learn. This theme serves as a powerful metaphor for the exclusionary policies that govern Palestinian life under occupation. The film's portrayal of these tensions is both unsentimental and deeply empathetic.
One of the standout performances comes from Mohammed Ghazaoui, who wins an award with his nearly silent portrayal of Khaled. His character's presence is marked by a quiet desperation, as he navigates a world where freedom to move and experience is curtailed at every turn.
Khalifa Natour delivers a similarly nuanced performance as Ribhi, Khaled's father, whose struggles are exacerbated by the occupation. Every phone call in Arabic is a gamble, as he faces suspicion from those around him. The tension builds as Ribhi sets out to find his son, facing the risks of being caught and deported.
The film's climax, which takes place in a bustling Tel Aviv café, serves as a powerful commentary on empathy and understanding. While some may interpret this finale as sentimental or manipulative, it feels instead like a nuanced exploration of human connection in the face of adversity.
Overall, "The Sea" is a moving tribute to the resilience and humanity of Palestinian youth under occupation. Pollak's direction masterfully balances the personal story of Khaled with the broader social context, offering a powerful critique of Israel's policies without resorting to simplistic solutions or polemic.
Shot in a straightforward style with an acute attention to detail, the film is elevated by its thoughtful collaboration between Jewish and Palestinian Israeli creatives. This genuine partnership not only lends authenticity to the story but also underscores the shared humanity at its core. By centering the voices of Palestinians, "The Sea" offers a vital contribution to the ongoing conversation about Israel's occupation – one that demands to be heard.
In an era where narratives often reinforce binary oppositions, Pollak's film is a rare gift: a deeply humanizing gaze that shows us the world through the eyes of those most affected by our policies. "The Sea" may not offer easy solutions or comforting platitudes; it instead invites us to confront the complexities and tensions at the heart of this conflict – and perhaps, just perhaps, to see ourselves in Khaled's quiet determination to experience life beyond his village's borders.
- not because it's trying to upset you, but because it's showing you the harsh realities of life under occupation. I'm all for nuance and complexity, but sometimes I feel like these kinds of stories are more about empathy than they are about actual change 
. Don't get me wrong, "The Sea" is still a powerful watch - the performances are on point, especially Mohammed Ghazaoui's portrayal of Khaled 
. But can we talk about how this film reinforces the narrative that Palestinians are just waiting for someone to come and rescue them? I think Pollak does a great job of humanizing Khaled, but let's not forget that he's still trapped in a system that doesn't want him to be free 
. Anyways, it's definitely worth a watch - just don't say I didn't warn you 
.
. I mean, I can appreciate the nuance in Pollak's direction and the performances from Mohammed Ghazaoui and Khalifa Natour, but isn't it just going to reinforce the narrative that Palestinians are always the victims here? 
And what's with all the focus on language and borders - doesn't that just sound like more of the same old talking points from both sides? 
. And let's be real, the fact that it's getting Oscar buzz is just more proof that Hollywood loves to co-opt socially conscious themes and pretend like they're making a difference 
. Give me something with actual substance over this feel-good nonsense 
.
.
. The way it humanizes the occupation and makes you think about our own complicity is really powerful 
. I love how the film brings together these different perspectives from Jewish and Palestinian Israeli creatives - it's a total testament to the power of collaboration and empathy 
. This movie is definitely going to spark some tough conversations, but in the best way possible 
.
! It's like, finally someone is making a film that truly gets what's going on with the occupation and it's not just some simplistic story. Shai Carmeli Pollak is a genius for tackling this super sensitive topic with such nuance and empathy 
. The way the film weaves together Khaled's personal journey with the broader social context is so impressive – it feels really honest, you know? 
And that performance from Mohammed Ghazaoui? Chilling 
. It's like he's speaking straight to your soul. I'm also loving how the film highlights the complexities of language and borders – it's so relevant right now 
. Can we get a world tour screening for this film ASAP? 
and I'm still reeling from the beauty of it all. The way the light danced across the rice fields was like nothing I've ever seen before. And have you guys tried those new iced coffee drinks that are everywhere on Instagram? They're literally the perfect pick-me-up for a lazy Sunday morning 
️
and face so much danger on the way to get there... i think its great that the film tries to humanize both sides of the conflict 
especially Mohammed Ghazaoui as Khaled, his quiet desperation really adds depth to the story.
I'm so glad we finally have a film that dares to humanize the occupation without resorting to clichés 
. The cinematography is on point, capturing the disconnect between Tel Aviv's affluent bubble and the harsh realities outside 
. And Khaled's struggle to learn Hebrew is literally heartbreaking 
- it's like he's trying to speak his way into a world that doesn't want him there 
his struggle to learn Hebrew is like me trying to remember what day it is every morning 
but seriously, the way the film shows the contrast between these 2 worlds is wild 
️
the cinematography is also fire 
. It's not some grand statement about politics, but a honest portrayal of life as a Palestinian kid growing up under Israeli rule 
.
they're just trying to live their lives and be free, like anyone else... and Khaled's story is SO relatable 
i mean, who hasn't felt trapped by rules or restrictions at some point? 
the way Pollak balances personal and social context is masterful - it's not about simplifying complex issues, but rather showing us that everyone's got a story worth hearing 