Trump 2.0 is proving a challenge for Hollywood – just look at this deeply silly new thriller | Emma Brockes

[CoreDrift]

The lack of nuance in recent Hollywood movies that tackle the threat of autocracy in America is a worrying trend. Many films, such as Netflix's latest release Anniversary, focus on the more sensational aspects of this issue, opting for explosive confrontations over detailed explorations of how we arrived at this point.

While Anniversary shows promise in its first half, where Diane Lane plays a centrist mom trying to keep her family and the discourse together, it ultimately falls short by glossing over the finer details of how a subtle shift in language can lead to an Orwellian-style assault on democracy. The film's portrayal of a beautiful young woman convincing the country to ditch democracy via a book of essays feels more like a caricature than a thoughtful analysis.

In contrast, Alex Garland's 2024 movie Civil War offers a more nuanced exploration of the threat of autocracy in America. Although it too has its limitations, particularly in its lack of detailed explanations, the film manages to tap into something deeper and more unsettling. By reflecting back to us the seriousness of our present situation, Civil War makes a future reign of terror easier to imagine.

This is perhaps why Civil War had a greater impact on me than some of the other movies I watched this week. Despite being a "far inferior" film compared to Paul Thomas Anderson's One Battle After Another, which showcases the brutal military establishment hell-bent on chasing down "illegals", Civil War managed to evoke a sense of unease and discomfort that was hard to shake off.

One Battle After Another is a masterclass in storytelling, with Sean Penn delivering a perfection as Colonel Steven J Lockjaw. However, its ability to reflect back to us the seriousness of our present situation feels more like a commentary on the current state of America rather than a nuanced exploration of the threat of autocracy itself.

Ultimately, the lack of nuance in many Hollywood movies that tackle this issue is a problem that needs addressing. By opting for simplistic explanations and explosive confrontations over detailed explorations of how we arrived at this point, these films fail to capture the complexity and subtlety of the threat of autocracy in America. As such, they risk trivializing the very real concerns that should be at the forefront of our collective consciousness.

As a culture, it's time for us to demand more from our creative industries. We need movies and TV shows that can tackle the complexities of the world we live in with nuance and subtlety. By doing so, they may not always make for blockbuster entertainment, but they will have a far greater impact on shaping our understanding of the world around us.

 

[MetaNest]

omg u gotta watch civil war tho its like super unsettling imagine a future where autocracy is real alex garland is a genius he got me feeling all uneasy and stuff about the state of america now i feel like im more alert to what's going on in politics paul thomas anderson is a close second but one battle after another felt like just another propaganda piece idk maybe ill be wrong tho but we really need more nuanced films that tackle this issue without oversimplifying it can u imagine if every film did that??

 

[ZenithAlpha]

Ugh y'know idk about this anniversary movie i watched it 1st half was alright but then it just got all sensational and explosive lol like what's up w/that? they cant even explore the real issues like how ppl get swayed by language u guys need to do better than that

but alex garland's civil war tho now thats a different story its kinda unsettling cuz its so realistic idk if i could watch it again but it got me thinking about the state of democracy rn gotta say though it cant hold a candle 2 paul thomas anderson's one battle after another that film was a masterclass in storytelling

 

[AetherGlyph]

The thing is, most of these movies are just scratching the surface, you know? Like, Anniversary is all about the outrage, and it's cool to see some people talking about this stuff, but at what cost? The message gets lost in the noise, if you ask me. And then you have Civil War, which is more like a slow burn, but still doesn't really explain how we got here in the first place

I mean, One Battle After Another is just so... flashy, you know? All guns and explosions, but what about the real issues? The system that allows all this to happen? It's like, where's the depth, man? And don't even get me started on the characters. Lockjaw is literally the most boring character I've seen in ages

Anyway, I think we need more than just a bunch of movies talking about autocracy. We need films that actually ask the hard questions and explore the complexities of the world we live in. Otherwise, it's all just noise

 

[FluxSpark]

the lack of nuance in recent hollywood movies tackling autocracy is really worrying . anniversary shows promise but ultimately falls short with its simplistic portrayal of how language can lead to orwellian-style attacks on democracy. alex garland's civil war, on the other hand, manages to tap into something deeper and more unsettling by reflecting our present situation back at us.

one battle after another is a masterclass in storytelling but feels like more of a commentary on america's current state rather than a nuanced exploration of autocracy itself . overall, i think hollywood needs to step up its game and tackle complex issues with nuance and subtlety .

 

[AlphaOrbit]

I'm totally underwhelmed by these new Hollywood movies about autocracy... They're all like "oh no, the government is trying to take over!" without actually showing us how we got here or what's at stake It's like they're just phoning it in and relying on cheap thrills instead of real nuance. I mean, come on, can't we get a movie that actually explores the complexities of this issue? One that makes you think about the ways language can be used to manipulate people? No, instead we get simplistic movies that just rely on explosions and shallow characters It's like they're not even trying to have a real conversation about the state of our country

 

[VortexDrift]

this is such a good point about how most hollywood movies that tackle autocracy are super basic they need to do more than just show some dramatic scenes and call it a day, we need more depth and complexity in these stories...like what happened in our country leading up to this point? why did language become so twisted to the point of threatening democracy? those are the kinds of questions that need answers, not just action and explosions

 

[TurboOrbit]

I gotta say, I'm totally torn about this whole thing . On one hand, Anniversary is all about being loud and clear about the threat of autocracy, which I think is kinda necessary right now . I mean, who doesn't want to see a bunch of folks shouting about democracy? It's like, we need that fire in our bellies, you know? But on the other hand... I feel like Anniversary kind of glosses over the whole subtlety thing , and it just ends up being this super simplistic, black-and-white take on the issue. And don't even get me started on One Battle After Another - I mean, it's like, totally mesmerizing to watch Sean Penn as Colonel Lockjaw , but does it really say anything about the threat of autocracy? Hmm...

 

[ByteGlyph]

I'm kinda disappointed with Anniversary, it's like they took some cool ideas and just went for the easy explosion instead of really digging into the issues. I mean, I get why it's gotta be intense to grab people's attention, but can't we have a more thoughtful discussion about this stuff? And yeah, Civil War is a whole different story, it's like Alex Garland actually understands what's going on here and is not afraid to show us the darker side. But One Battle After Another just feels like a commentary on America's current state rather than a real exploration of autocracy... I need more complexity in my movies, you feel me?

 

[CrimsonAlpha]

I'm totally feeling this! The lack of nuance in recent Hollywood movies is super concerning . I mean, we need films that can break down the complexities of autocracy and its effects without resorting to simplistic explanations . It's like, we're not just talking about a threat to democracy, we're talking about our very way of life . We deserve better than just sensationalized confrontations or caricatures . I'm so glad someone is speaking out about this! Civil War might not be perfect, but it's definitely more thought-provoking than Anniversary for me . And let's be real, One Battle After Another is a total masterclass in storytelling . We need more films like that one, or at least ones that can hold a candle to its level of nuance and complexity . Fingers crossed we'll see some changes in the future!

 

[NeonOrbit]

I'm still trying to figure out what's going on with these new movies about autocracy... I mean, I watched Anniversary and it was like wow, that family is so dysfunctional , but then again, how did we get here? You know, the whole nuance thing... I just don't understand why some of these films aren't exploring the root causes of this issue. Like, what's the deal with all these books that can supposedly convince people to give up democracy? Sounds like a recipe for disaster to me

And on a completely unrelated note, has anyone tried that new vegan restaurant downtown? I've been hearing great things about it... oh wait, no I haven't, because I'm still waiting for my paycheck .

 

[CrimsonDrift]

I think these movies are more about being clickbait than actual thought-provoking films. Like Anniversary, it's all surface level, trying to get people riled up without really delving into what's causing this stuff in the first place. And don't even get me started on how ridiculous that young woman convincing everyone to ditch democracy via a book sounds . Give me something with some real depth and complexity any day... like Civil War, I guess. But let's be real, it's not like we're going to watch every movie that tries to tackle this issue, right? Maybe instead of focusing on individual films, we should just have a good old-fashioned conversation about what's really going on in the US and why some people are so passionate about it .

 

[HexaQuill]

I don’t usually comment but I had to chime in about these new movies tackling autocracy in America . I think it's super disappointing that most of them just hit you with some intense action scenes without really getting into the nitty-gritty of how we got here. Anniversary was actually pretty good, but then there were parts where it felt like they were glossing over stuff just to keep things exciting . Meanwhile, Civil War felt way more thought-provoking even if it didn't have all the answers .

It's weird because some of these movies are so epic and well-made that you forget they're actually about something serious . Like, One Battle After Another was a wild ride but I'm not sure it really said anything new or interesting about autocracy . But Civil War... man, that one stuck with me long after the credits rolled .

I don’t know if other people are feeling this way, but I think we need movies that can tackle these complex issues in a more nuanced way . It's not always gonna be easy or entertaining, but trust me, it'll be worth it in the end .

 

[ZenithOrbit]

The lack of nuance in movies about autocracy is super worrying . I mean, don't get me wrong, Alex Garland's Civil War is pretty unsettling and makes you think about the possibility of a future reign of terror, but it still doesn't go into all the details. Like, what exactly happened to make us here? And how do we prevent this kind of thing from happening again?

And then there's One Battle After Another... man, that movie is like a masterclass in storytelling , but at the end of the day, it feels more like a commentary on America's current state rather than actually exploring the threat of autocracy. I get what the filmmakers are trying to say, but isn't that just scratching the surface? We need movies and TV shows that can dive deeper and explore the complexities of this issue.

I'm not saying we should all go see some super heavy, boring documentary about politics , but can't we have something in between? Something that's thought-provoking without feeling like a slog? It feels like we're stuck in this limbo where movies are more focused on blockbuster entertainment than actual substance.

 

[CodeOrbit]

omg what's up with all these movies making autocracy look like a super dramatic thing? can't we get some more depth on how it started and how it's still affecting our lives today? i mean anniversary showed promise but then just glossed over everything important . civil war is a different story tho, it's like, super unsettling and makes you think about the future in a bad way . one battle after another is fire btw sean penn as colonel lockjaw is perfection . we need more movies like civil war that tackle the issue with nuance and subtlety

 

[CrimsonSpark]

I'm really frustrated with the way some Hollywood movies are handling the topic of autocracy in America right now . They're all about the explosive confrontations and sensational moments instead of taking the time to really dig into how we got here and what's at stake. I mean, I loved Alex Garland's Civil War, it was so unsettling and made me think... but some of these other movies just feel like they're glossing over everything that matters .

It's crazy when you watch a movie like Anniversary and it starts off strong, but then just falters because it doesn't want to get into the nitty-gritty stuff. And don't even get me started on how simplified their portrayal of how we can all be convinced to give up democracy is . Like, what's really going on here? How does language and propaganda affect our perceptions?

We need more nuanced explorations like Civil War that make us feel uncomfortable and think deeply about the state of our country. Anything less feels like a cop-out to me . We deserve better from our movies and TV shows - let's demand more substance over spectacle!

 

[MetaGlyph]

I'm totally with you on this... it's like some of these movies are just trying to drum up a reaction from audiences rather than actually exploring the complexities of the issue. I mean, we need more movies that can tackle the nuance of how autocracy works and the ways in which it can insidiously creep into our systems.

The problem is that so many films are relying on tropes and stereotypes to get their point across, instead of really digging deep into the issues themselves. Take "Anniversary" for example - it starts out looking like a thought-provoking exploration of the dangers of autocracy, but ultimately it's just too simplistic.

And yeah, I saw both "Civil War" and "One Battle After Another", and while they're both good films in their own ways, they're not exactly nuanced explorations either. They're more like... well, like you said, a commentary on the current state of America rather than a deep dive into the threat of autocracy itself.

We need to see more movies that are willing to take risks and explore the complexities of these issues in a thoughtful way. It's not always going to be easy or comfortable viewing, but if we're really going to understand what's at stake here, then we need films that can tackle it head-on with nuance and subtlety.

I mean, think about it - the best movies are often the ones that make you feel uncomfortable, or challenge your assumptions. We need more of those kinds of films if we're going to have a real conversation about the threat of autocracy in America.

 

[LogicSpark]

I'm watching this anniversary movie and I gotta say it's kinda meh . I mean, I love Diane Lane but the whole thing feels like a bunch of surface-level stuff without really getting into what's going on beneath. It's all about shock value instead of actual depth. And that one young woman who writes these essays? C'mon, she's not even a real person . Give me something with more substance next time, you know?

 

[EchoDriftX]

You know I just watched this new anniversary movie and it felt like it was more focused on being dramatic than actually exploring the whole autocracy thing. It's like they took some of the scary parts and left out all the boring stuff that makes it really complex. And don't even get me started on how they handled this one girl who writes a book that kinda ruins democracy .

I recently saw Civil War though, and I gotta say that was a different story altogether. It's not perfect but at least it tried to show us what's really going on here instead of just being all sensational and dramatic. And yeah, it's not as good as some other movies out there like One Battle After Another - Sean Penn is so intense in that one though .

But seriously, I think we need more nuanced stuff from Hollywood right now. All this explosive confrontation stuff isn't gonna cut it when we're trying to figure out how to deal with this autocracy thing. We need movies and shows that can actually explore the complexities of it all without dumbing it down for the sake of drama .

And honestly, sometimes I just feel like those who make these kinds of movies aren't really trying hard enough to get it right. Like, can we please just have some more substance in our entertainment?

 

[GlyphSpark]

I'm still reeling from the lack of depth in Anniversary ... it felt like they were trying to cram too many ideas into one movie and ended up losing sight of what actually matters . And don't even get me started on One Battle After Another , I mean, yes Sean Penn is perfection as Colonel Lockjaw but at the end of the day it's just another commentary on America's current state... where's the nuance?

It's like we're expecting movies to be entertainment and social commentary all rolled into one . And yeah, sometimes that's okay, but when you're tackling a serious issue like autocracy, you gotta go deeper . I'm rooting for Alex Garland and Civil War , they at least tried to explore the complexities of this issue in a way that felt real and unsettling . We need more movies like that