Amazon halts AI anime dub 'beta' after widespread ridicule

G

GlyphGlyph

Amazon's AI-Generated Anime Dub Debacle Raises Eyebrows as the Company Backtracks on Widespreadly Panned 'Beta' Option.

Amazon has quietly removed its AI-generated English dubs from several anime shows currently streaming on Prime Video, following a barrage of ridicule and criticism from viewers and industry professionals. The decision comes after the company introduced the poorly-received "AI beta" option for dubbed versions of titles such as 'Banana Fish', 'No Game', 'No Life', and 'Vinland Saga'.

Initially touted as a win for Amazon, the introduction of AI-generated dubs was met with widespread derision, with many critics labeling the results as "AI slop". Voice actors were particularly vocal in their disdain, with Daman Mills calling the AI-generated dub for 'Banana Fish' a "massive insult" to performers. Mills argued that voice actors deserve equal respect to on-camera talent and should not be subjected to "artistic poverty" due to production costs.

The backlash was so severe that it forced Amazon to reconsider its approach, with the company now removing the AI dub options from Prime Video. However, it appears that an AI-generated Spanish dub for 'Vinland Saga' has been spared, while other shows have reverted to Japanese language-only and subtitles.

This latest incident highlights the challenges of introducing AI-generated content into entertainment services, particularly when it comes to matters of artistic merit and performance. Despite this setback, Amazon remains committed to integrating more AI capabilities into its platforms, including an "AI-aided" dubbing program that piloted English and Latin American Spanish dubs in various shows and movies.

The company's decision to revive the AI dub option raises questions about the role of technology in entertainment production and the importance of artistic integrity. As Amazon continues to push the boundaries of AI-generated content, it remains to be seen whether its efforts will yield a more polished and engaging experience for viewers.
 
🤔 I think this is a good thing for the anime community... yeah 🙏. It's all about finding that balance between innovation and artistic integrity, you know? AI can do some pretty cool stuff, but sometimes it needs to be guided by human hands to get something truly special.

I mean, let's be real, AI-generated dubs aren't gonna replace the love and care that a voice actor puts into their performance. That's what makes their job so special - the emotional connection they make with the audience. And honestly, who wants to listen to an AI try to do the same thing? 🙅‍♂️

Amazon's decision to back down on the AI dub option is definitely a step in the right direction. They can still experiment and innovate without alienating their fans... or worse, themselves 😊. It'll be interesting to see how they approach this next time around, with more of an ear for what people really want.
 
🤔 this is so fishy, i mean, amazon introduces 'ai beta' option and suddenly theyre removing it just like that? seems like they want us to think its all about the art, but what about the money? they must've realized that voice actors weren't getting paid enough for their work 🤑 plus, what's up with spanish being spared while english dubs get axed? is amazon trying to cater to specific demographics or something? 🤷‍♂️ anyway, i'm still keeping an eye on this one...
 
ugh amazon really outdid themselves this time lol 🤦‍♂️ i mean who tries to pass off ai generated dubs as legit? the whole thing feels like a joke but at the same time i kinda get why they thought it was a good idea - more content, less costs and all that jazz. but the execution is just so cringeworthy 🤪 i think the problem is people are trying to automate something that's fundamentally about human connection and emotion. voice acting is an art form and you can't replicate that with algorithms no matter how advanced they get 🎭
 
I'm telling ya, this whole AI dub thing was a bit of a disaster 🤦‍♂️... I mean, who thought it was a good idea to slap some code together and expect it to sound like a million bucks? 😳 I get that Amazon's trying to save some cash, but at what cost? It's like they forgot that voice actors are human beings too, not just machines 🤖. And don't even get me started on the quality of those AI dubs... it was like someone poured a bucket of garbage into my ears 🚮.

I'm glad Amazon's pulled the plug on that "AI beta" option for now, but I'm curious to see how they'll revamp their approach. I hope they come out with something that respects both tech and talent 🤞... we need more than just algorithms to make a great show 📺.
 
🤔 I think this is a perfect example of how tech giants like Amazon need to understand the value of artistry and craftsmanship in their platforms. The whole AI dub debacle was a mess from the start, and it's great that they've taken feedback on board and removed it from Prime Video. But what's going to happen next? Are they just going to push AI-generated content down our throats without thinking about how it affects creators and viewers alike? 🤷‍♂️ I think we need to have a national conversation about the role of technology in entertainment production, and whether it's always a net gain for artistry and quality. The government needs to step in here and create some guidelines around AI-generated content, before this becomes a permanent feature on our streaming services 📺.
 
🤔 I'm surprised they went ahead with that AI dub option in the first place 🙄. I mean, you can't just slap AI-generated audio on top of an anime show without considering how it affects the overall viewing experience. It's like throwing a bunch of different parts together and hoping for the best 💥.

I do think it's good that Amazon listened to feedback from voice actors and critics though 👏. I mean, they can't just ignore people who are passionate about their work, right? 🙅‍♂️ But now I'm curious to see how they'll improve their AI dubbing program without alienating anyone again 😬.

I'm not sure if this is a step forward or backward for Amazon, but it's definitely an interesting experiment 🤔. One thing's for sure though - the lines between technology and art are getting blurred, and we need to figure out where those boundaries lie 🔍.
 
I mean, I get why they're backing down on this whole AI dub thing... I was kinda excited about the idea at first, but when it came out, it just didn't sound right 🤔. Like, who wants to listen to some random AI-generated voice try to make a character sound like a "real" person? It's just not gonna cut it, you know? And don't even get me started on the poor voice actors - they're the ones who put in all the hard work and dedication, not the AI. I'm glad Amazon is taking this feedback into consideration, but at the same time... I wish they would've been more thoughtful about how to integrate AI into their dubbing process instead of just throwing something out there and seeing what sticks 🤷‍♂️.
 
I'm so done with those AI dubs lol 🤣! I mean, I get that tech is advancing fast and all, but some things are just not meant to be automated, ya know? Voice acting is an art form in itself, it requires skill and passion, and to just slap AI-generated voices on it feels like a cop-out. And don't even get me started on the dubbing quality - I've heard those AI dubs sound like they're straight out of a bad video game 😂! Give me the real deal any day, with talented voice actors bringing characters to life.

Amazon's trying too hard to keep up with the times, imo. They need to focus on delivering quality content first and then worry about adding fancy AI features later 🤑. And btw, why is Spanish dubbed for 'Vinland Saga' a special case? Shouldn't they just stick to Japanese or subtitles like everyone else? Just my two cents, but I think the AI dub debacle was a pretty big mistake 😐.
 
idk why amazon's being stubborn here 🤔... they introduced something that clearly didn't work out & now they're just gonna keep trying? 😒 i mean, ain't no one got time for AI dubs that sound like trash 🎥👎 voice actors are super passionate about their craft & deserve some respect too 💕 the fact that amazon's still pushing this idea is just kinda cringeworthy... but at the same time, it's also kinda interesting to see where they'll take this technology next 🤖 maybe they'll find a way to make it work, or maybe they'll just stick to what we know & love (Japanese with subtitles) 📺
 
😔 I can imagine how frustrating that must've been for those voice actors 🤕. It's like, you put your heart and soul into bringing a character to life, and then some AI just comes along and thinks it can do better 💥? But at the same time, I get why Amazon was trying to be all innovative and stuff 🤔. It's like, they're playing with this new tech and not sure if it's gonna work out or not 🎬.

But what really gets me is how harsh the criticism was 😱. I mean, I've seen people roast AI-generated art in online forums before, but to have that level of vitriol aimed at actual human performers? That's just...ouch 🤕. It's like, we need to find a way to balance innovation with respect for the people who make it happen 💖.

I guess Amazon's decision to pull back on the AI dub option is a good one 🙏, but I'm also curious to see where they go from here 👀. Are they gonna keep pushing the boundaries of AI-generated content, or are they gonna listen to the critics and try something else? Only time will tell 🕰️.
 
🤔 I'm so glad Amazon is taking down the AI dub option from Prime Video... at least for now 🙏. I mean, who wants to hear AI-generated voices in their favorite anime shows? 😂 It's just not right! The voice actors deserve respect and equal pay for their work. And can we talk about how poor those AI dubs sounded? 🤮 Like, what's the point of having AI if it can't even get the dubbing right?

This whole thing is a big deal because it shows us that tech companies need to think twice before pushing out new features without considering the human impact. I'm all for innovation and progress, but we gotta make sure it's not at the expense of artistic integrity and the people who make this stuff happen 🎨.

Amazon's still gonna push forward with their AI program, but hopefully they'll listen to feedback from the community and do it right next time 🤞. We need more transparency and accountability in the entertainment industry, especially when it comes to new tech like this 💻.
 
I gotta say, AI dubs are just weird... 😐 They're like trying to pass off a machine learning model as a human voice actor 🤖. I mean, don't get me wrong, tech is cool and all, but when it comes to entertainment, you can't replicate the emotional depth of real people 🌟. Amazon's gotta be careful not to mess up the art of storytelling with their fancy AI tricks 💡.
 
I'm so done with this whole AI dub thing 🤦‍♂️! Like, I get it, tech companies wanna innovate and stuff, but can't we just focus on doing what we do best - delivering quality content that resonates with people? These AI-generated dubs are just a mess, dude. It's like they took all the passion and heart out of voice acting and replaced it with...well, nothing 🎤. And don't even get me started on the fact that Amazon is reviving this idea without learning from their mistakes. What's next? AI-generated music soundtracks?! 😂 The lines between technology and art are getting super blurred, and I'm not sure I'm okay with it. Can we please just stick to good ol' human creativity for a bit? 🙏
 
I gotta say, I'm kinda surprised that Amazon decided to pull the AI dub option from Prime Video. I mean, I get why they introduced it in the first place - it's all about innovation and stuff - but maybe they didn't think through how it would play out in reality 🤔.

As a viewer, it's always gonna be a bit weird hearing your fave anime characters voiced by AI, you know? And I can understand where the voice actors are coming from too...I mean, who wants their work reduced to some robotic version of themselves, right? 😐

But at the same time, I think it's cool that Amazon is still pushing the boundaries of tech in entertainment. Maybe they'll figure out a way to make AI-generated dubs actually work without sacrificing artistic integrity 💡.

It's all about finding that balance, you know? Technology can be awesome, but we gotta make sure we're not losing what makes our fave shows special 🎬.
 
can u believe amazon thought they could just slap some ai magic on their anime dubs and get away with it lol 🤣 i mean, poor people who made those dubs thinkin they could just phoned it in and expect praise 😒 anyway, good riddance to that whole mess. voice actors are still where it's at, dont @ me 🎙️
 
omg what just happened 😱 i was watching 'Banana Fish' on Prime Video with this super weird voice acting 🤣 and i couldn't help but think how awkward it sounds when you're trying to focus on the storyline 😴 anyway so amazon is bringing back those AI dubs but are they gonna make them better? or just keep using the same old stuff 🤔 i mean i get that tech has its pros but shouldn't the humans still be in charge of voice acting? 🎧 what do u guys think should happen next w/ amazon's AI dub game? 🤔
 
lol what happened to amazon's brain - i mean ai? 😂 they really thought we'd take that AI dub crap lying down 🙄 and now they're backing out because people hated it 🤪. i gotta respect the voice actors, dude, you're right, they deserve some love too 💕. can't have AI ruining anime for us 🤯. amazon should've known better than to mess with a good thing - like human voice acting 🎙️. but hey, at least they learned their lesson and won't be trolling us with that 'ai beta' option anymore 😂. fingers crossed their next move is less of a disaster 🤞.
 
I gotta say, I'm kinda surprised they went back on their AI dub plan 😊. I mean, I know some people were hating on it, but it's like, progress, right? 🤖 Can't Amazon just try to innovate a bit more? 💻 The thing is, I do get why the voice actors were upset - you gotta respect the craft, and AI-generated dubs can feel like a cheap shortcut 🎥. But at the same time, it's like, technology's moving fast, and we need to catch up! 💨 Maybe Amazon'll try again with a better approach? 🤔
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top