NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch has accepted a job offer from incoming Mayor Zohran Mamdani, but despite their shared goals, there are areas where they don't see eye to eye. In statements announcing the appointment, both Tisch and Mamdani emphasized the importance of lowering crime rates and fighting corruption within the NYPD.
However, in a message to department members, Tisch acknowledged that she doesn't share her new boss's views on every issue. "The reason I have chosen to stay is you," she wrote. "Now, do the Mayor-elect and I agree on everything? No, we don't." This sentiment was echoed by Mamdani in a phone interview after the announcement, where he stated that disagreements are not only reconcilable but also a sign of a healthy partnership.
One area of disagreement appears to be bail reform. Tisch has been an outspoken critic of New York state's reforms, which she believes contributed to the city's spike in crime during the COVID-19 pandemic. In contrast, Mamdani expressed support for the reforms and their importance in addressing social injustices.
Another point of contention is policing of protests. Tisch has overseen increased quality of life enforcement by the NYPD, which includes responding to minor offenses like noise complaints and double parking. This approach has drawn criticism from criminal justice reform advocates, who argue that such efforts can lead to further marginalization of already vulnerable communities.
Mamdani's proposal for a Department of Community Safety, which would send mental health professionals to help New Yorkers in distress, also raises questions about how it will interact with the NYPD. While both Tisch and Mamdani stated that they want to ensure collaboration between the two entities, critics remain skeptical about the potential for further entanglement of law enforcement with social services.
The Police Benevolent Association welcomed the appointment of a stable and experienced leader in Tisch, citing her understanding of the challenges faced by police officers. Despite their differences, both Tisch and Mamdani appear committed to finding common ground and working towards a shared vision for public safety.
However, in a message to department members, Tisch acknowledged that she doesn't share her new boss's views on every issue. "The reason I have chosen to stay is you," she wrote. "Now, do the Mayor-elect and I agree on everything? No, we don't." This sentiment was echoed by Mamdani in a phone interview after the announcement, where he stated that disagreements are not only reconcilable but also a sign of a healthy partnership.
One area of disagreement appears to be bail reform. Tisch has been an outspoken critic of New York state's reforms, which she believes contributed to the city's spike in crime during the COVID-19 pandemic. In contrast, Mamdani expressed support for the reforms and their importance in addressing social injustices.
Another point of contention is policing of protests. Tisch has overseen increased quality of life enforcement by the NYPD, which includes responding to minor offenses like noise complaints and double parking. This approach has drawn criticism from criminal justice reform advocates, who argue that such efforts can lead to further marginalization of already vulnerable communities.
Mamdani's proposal for a Department of Community Safety, which would send mental health professionals to help New Yorkers in distress, also raises questions about how it will interact with the NYPD. While both Tisch and Mamdani stated that they want to ensure collaboration between the two entities, critics remain skeptical about the potential for further entanglement of law enforcement with social services.
The Police Benevolent Association welcomed the appointment of a stable and experienced leader in Tisch, citing her understanding of the challenges faced by police officers. Despite their differences, both Tisch and Mamdani appear committed to finding common ground and working towards a shared vision for public safety.
I'm a bit concerned about this new development. As someone who's followed Jessica Tisch's work with NYPD, it's interesting that she'd criticize the state's bail reform but then accept a role under Mamdani, who supports those reforms. It seems like a contradiction to me. What's more, I don't think policing of protests is the right approach - what about all the times police have been criticized for their treatment of protesters? Maybe we need to rethink our approach to community safety instead?
anyway, bail reform is super important especially when it comes to vulnerable communities like low-income folks & people of color 
what's worse, policing protests or addressing actual social issues? 
. And don't even get me started on policing protests 
... Tisch's approach just seems so... soft 
. I mean, I get where she's coming from with quality of life enforcement and all, but at what cost? 
, can you believe it? The new NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch is already hinting that she might not see eye to eye with the Mayor-elect on some major issues 
, like bail reform! I'm all about supporting bail reform, it's so crucial in reducing mass incarceration and addressing systemic injustices 
. Meanwhile, Mamdani's plan for a Department of Community Safety sounds super intriguing 
, she seems like an amazing leader who genuinely cares about policing reform. Fingers crossed that her experience & expertise will help find common ground with Mamdani 
, can't wait to see how this partnership unfolds 
he's gonna try to merge the police with social services, it's like they're trying to control our minds 
have you seen the way tisch is trying to cover up her own agenda? she's all like "oh, i'm just here for the cops, not for mamdani" 
guess we'll just hav to see how its all playd out 
People don't have to see eye-to-eye on everything to be able to hear each other out. You can have differing opinions and still come to a place of mutual respect. 
The key is not to force agreements, but to find common ground through active listening. 
. How can we really make a difference when it feels like everyone's just trying to play by different rules? 
Bail reform is gonna be a big one, and if Tisch has been speaking out against those reforms, that's bound to make things interesting. I mean, Mamdani's stance on social injustices might lead to some heavy debates... but hey, at least they're both trying to find common ground? 
What do you think about a Department of Community Safety tho? Should the NYPD and mental health services just collab or what?
It's a tough spot to be in, fam 
. but bail reform is a tough one 
. maybe mamdani's proposal on community safety will help bridge that gap 
? as for policing protests, idk man... seems like an either/or situation to me