The Guardian view on Europe's stalling night train revival: don't let it hit the buffers | Editorial

Europe's Night Train Revival Stalls as Governments Fail to Address Challenges

The European Union's ambitious goal of achieving net zero carbon emissions by 2050 has sparked excitement about reviving the continent's beloved night trains. Once a staple of romantic getaways, these long-distance journeys were thought to be a thing of the past with the rise of budget airlines and short-haul flights. However, as governments grapple with the environmental implications of their actions, it appears that the renaissance of night trains is on the brink of collapse.

The European Commission had identified numerous potential new routes for night trains, citing their lower carbon footprint compared to flying. In fact, a single night train journey could emit 28 times less CO2 than a short-haul flight. However, despite this promising start, many initiatives have stalled due to inadequate funding and regulatory hurdles.

A prime example of this is the scrapped Paris-Vienna-Berlin night service, which was shut down after state subsidies were withdrawn. The French operator, SNCF, cited high operational costs as a major obstacle to reviving the route. Similarly, plans for a new Basel-Copenhagen-Malmö night train have been derailed due to the withdrawal of state funding.

So what's behind this lack of progress? Demand is definitely there, with occupancy rates for popular routes reaching up to 70%. In fact, a recent YouGov survey found that 69% of respondents in key European countries were willing to take night trains on shorter journeys. However, the reality is that existing infrastructure and regulatory frameworks are hindering growth.

VAT charges and track access fees pose a significant obstacle to expanding the night train network. Aviation enjoys exemption from VAT charges, while rail travel is often subject to higher tariffs for longer routes. This creates an uneven playing field, making it difficult for rail operators to compete with air travel.

Furthermore, the lack of new rolling stock means that trains are being deployed with aging carriages, which cannot meet modern safety standards. As a result, services are booking up months in advance, leaving many passengers without access to this desirable mode of transport.

To revive the night train network and make it more appealing to the public, governments must take drastic action. This includes dropping VAT charges on cross-border routes, reducing or suspending track access fees, and providing financial backing for struggling operators. Investors are deterred by the uncertainty surrounding a nascent market, but with the right support and strategic thinking, the EU can unlock a more sustainable future for long-distance travel.

As popular support for night trains continues to grow – with over 75,000 people signing a petition to preserve a popular route – it's time for policymakers to listen. The mystique of a night-time journey across a sleeping continent still captivates millions of Europeans, and with the right investment and vision, this can be turned into tangible environmental gains that benefit both passengers and the planet.
 
I'm still thinking about the EU's night train revival... 🚂 I mean, it's crazy to think that one night train journey could emit 28 times less CO2 than a short-haul flight! But seriously, what's going on here? 🤔 The EU's got this huge goal of achieving net zero carbon emissions by 2050 and you'd think reviving the night trains would be a no-brainer.

But then there's all these issues with funding and regulations... VAT charges and track access fees are just too high for rail operators to compete with air travel. And don't even get me started on the lack of new rolling stock! 🚫 Aging carriages that can't meet modern safety standards? That's just a recipe for disaster.

I'm still waiting for some politician to step up and say, "You know what? We're going to make this work." 💪 Because let's face it, demand is there. People love the idea of taking the night train, especially on shorter journeys. But if governments don't get their act together, we'll just be stuck with outdated infrastructure and a whole lot of carbon emissions.

I'm still curious... when are they going to take drastic action? 🤔 Are they waiting for someone to sign a petition for them? Over 75,000 people signing a petition isn't going to make a difference if governments aren't willing to listen.
 
🚂😕 It's so frustrating to see the EU's ambitious goal for net zero carbon emissions hit a roadblock due to funding issues 🤑💸. We all know that night trains are a game-changer for sustainable travel, reducing CO2 emissions by up to 28 times compared to flights ✈️. But without adequate investment and regulatory support, these routes will just remain in the "to-do" list indefinitely 📝. The demand is there, with occupancy rates reaching up to 70% and a whopping 69% of Europeans willing to take night trains – but it's time for governments to step up their game 🔄. We need those VAT charges and track access fees to be dropped ASAP ⚠️. Let's get this train rolling again (pun intended) and make our continent a cleaner, greener place 🌳💚 #NightTrainsMatter #SustainableTravel #EUAction
 
"Believe you can and you're halfway there." 🚂💨
Governments need to step up and address the challenges facing night trains in Europe - it's time for them to invest in a more sustainable future for long-distance travel.
The EU has ambitious goals, but without drastic action from policymakers, these plans will continue to stall. With over 75,000 people signing a petition, there's clear demand for change.
It's not just about the environment - night trains are also an iconic part of European culture and history, offering a unique experience that can't be replicated by short-haul flights.
So let's hope that governments will listen to the public and take action to revive the night train network. After all, as the saying goes, "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." 🚫
 
🤔 I'm tellin' ya, there's something fishy goin' on here... Governments just seem to be stringin' us along while they're playin' with the strings of big business. Those VAT charges and track access fees are just a way to keep the rail operators in check and maintain the status quo. 🤑 And let's not forget about all those aging carriages - it's like they want to keep the trains old-school so we don't think twice about flyin'. ✈️ I mean, what's really goin' on behind closed doors? It's all about control and profiteering... Wake up, sheeple! 😴
 
I'm not buying it 🙄. They're just making excuses for why the night train revival is stalled. The EU's all about greenwashing 🌿. All this talk about reducing carbon emissions but they're still not addressing the root problem: infrastructure costs 💸. And don't even get me started on VAT charges and track access fees – it's like they want to strangle the rail industry 🚫. They need to think outside the box (or train, in this case) and come up with creative solutions that benefit both passengers and the environment 🤔. This whole thing smells like a PR stunt to me 📰. Where's the hard data? Where are the studies on how night trains can be more efficient than flying? Until they can answer those questions, I'm not convinced 💯.
 
the govts r really messin up here 🤦‍♂️... just think about it, these night trains are a way to reduce carbon emissions & they're gettin' scrapped because of funding issues 🤑... like, what's the point of tryin' to save the planet if we can't even support our own transport systems? 💸 and yeah, VAT charges & track access fees r killin' it for rail travel 🚂😩... i mean, come on, just make it fair for everyone! ✌️ we need more investment in this area, not less 📈... and let's be real, people wanna take those night trains 🛫️ they're romantic, scenic, & convenient - why can't govts get that? 😂
 
the EU needs to step up its game when it comes to reviving those night trains 🚂🌃 - it's not just about saving the environment, but also about making it more accessible for people who want a unique travel experience without breaking the bank 💸. the fact that governments are failing to address these challenges is super frustrating 🤯, and the lack of new rolling stock is just plain old-fashioned 🚫. what's needed is some serious investment in infrastructure and deregulation - if the EU wants to be a leader in sustainable travel, it needs to get its act together 💪!
 
[Image of a tired train conductor waving goodbye as a plane takes off in the background](😴🛫️)

[GIF of a clock running backwards, with a "night train" logo superimposed over it](⏪🚂)

[A picture of a person sitting on a night train, surrounded by luggage and smiling at a scenic view outside the window](😊🌄)

[Image of a graph showing a decline in air travel's carbon footprint, with a "night train" icon overlaid on top](📈🚂)

[GIF of a map of Europe with night trains connecting major cities, each one sparking a fireworks explosion](⭐🚂]

[A screenshot of the YouGov survey results, showing 69% in favor of taking night trains](🤝🌆
 
🚂😐 I'm all for reviving the night train network in Europe, but we need to address these major hurdles first 🤯. The EU's goal of net zero carbon emissions by 2050 is ambitious, but it's crucial to consider the practicalities 🌎. If governments just throw money at the problem without fixing these issues, they'll just be throwing good money after bad 💸.

VAT charges and track access fees are a major obstacle, and we can't keep making excuses about why rail travel should be treated unfairly compared to air travel 🤦‍♂️. We need to level the playing field and make it easier for operators to compete with airlines ✈️. And let's not forget that aging rolling stock is a safety concern – we can't just ignore that 💥.

I'm glad there's still demand for night trains, but we need concrete solutions, not just empty promises 📝. Governments need to get serious about reducing emissions and making sustainable travel more accessible to everyone 🌈. This isn't just about the environment; it's about creating a better future for European travelers 🗺️.
 
I'm so over all this fuss about reviving night trains 🙄. It's just not viable. I mean, sure, they might have lower carbon emissions or whatever, but who wants to spend hours stuck on a train with no Wi-Fi? Not me 😂. And don't even get me started on the occupancy rates – 70% is still a tiny fraction of people who'd actually use them regularly. I think the whole thing is just a feel-good policy that's never going to deliver on its promises. Governments should focus on more pressing issues, like getting our high-speed rail network up and running instead of chasing some pie-in-the-sky environmental goal 🚂💨
 
can't believe eu is struggling with reviving night trains again 🚂😩. governments keep saying they want to reduce carbon emissions but it seems like they're not willing to back up those claims. vat charges and track access fees are ridiculous - shouldn't rail travel be on par with air travel when it comes to tax? also, why do we still have aging carriages that can't meet safety standards? 🤔

i'm all for night trains but it's getting frustrating seeing them get shelved due to bureaucratic red tape. with demand being so high and occupancy rates reaching 70%, you'd think they'd be more willing to invest in the infrastructure and make it happen. instead, we're stuck in limbo while people continue to sign petitions and call for change 📣.

governments need to step up their game and stop making promises that aren't backed by action. with the right support and investment, night trains could be a sustainable alternative to flying and help reduce carbon emissions. let's hope they get their act together soon ⏰
 
I'm really surprised by how stuck we've gotten on reviving our night train network 🤦‍♂️. I mean, it's not like people aren't clamoring for it – they are! Occupancy rates are up to 70% already, and a YouGov survey says 69% of Europeans would love to take a night train on shorter journeys 😊. It just doesn't make sense that we're letting bureaucracy get in the way.

I think one of the biggest issues here is that aviation gets a free pass when it comes to VAT charges – rail travel has to pay more, which creates an uneven playing field 🤑. And don't even get me started on track access fees – they're just ridiculous 💸.

Another problem is our aging infrastructure; trains are still using carriages from the 90s or even earlier 🚂. It's a safety nightmare, and it's no wonder services are booking up months in advance.

To really make progress, governments need to take bold action. They need to drop VAT charges on cross-border routes, reduce track access fees, and give struggling operators some serious financial backing 💸. We can't just sit around waiting for investors to come along – we need policymakers to step up and show us that they're committed to making this work 🙏.

It's time for the EU to get its act together and make night trains a reality again. With the right investment and vision, I genuinely believe we could unlock some amazing environmental gains that would benefit both passengers and the planet 🌎.
 
man i just had the craziest dream last night 🌙💤 where i was on one of those iconic night trains in europe, but instead of being all classy and stuff, it was like a giant party car with flashing lights and music blasting through the speakers 🎉🔊. people were dancing in the aisles and having the best time, and at some point, we even stopped at a station that was literally in the middle of nowhere, but everyone just got off to explore this tiny village with the cutest little shops and cafes 🏙️🍰. anyway, back to real life...
 
I don’t usually comment but it seems like EU governments are playing a major role in slowing down Europe's night train revival 🚂😔 They keep putting obstacles in the way of progress without realizing how much people want this service to come back 😕 It’s not just about funding, there should be some kind of tax break on cross-border routes to make it more competitive with flying ✈️ And those track access fees are a major turn-off for operators 🚫 The EU has ambitious goals and night trains could be a key part of that but we need some serious push from the powers that be 💪
 
omg i totally get why they're struggling rn it makes sense that the EU would wanna save the environment 🌎 but the funding and regulations gotta change ASAP ⏰ snrf is literally crying out for help over here 🤦‍♀️ those occupancy rates are insane 70% of people wanna ride night trains lol let's make it happen!! 💥 we need to get those governments on board 💼 and stop being soooo bureaucratic 😴 let's drop the VAT charges and track access fees already! 🚂💸
 
🚂😔 Europe's Night Train Revival is going down the drain because governments are too chicken to make things happen 🐓. They're all about talking the talk but not walking the walk 🤷‍♂️. The EU has got the data on how much less carbon trains emit compared to flights, so why can't they just give rail operators a break and drop those VAT charges? 🤑 It's like they're more worried about keeping airlines happy than saving the planet 🌎. And don't even get me started on track access fees - it's like they want to strangle the industry before it even starts 🚫. The people are demanding change, but governments need to step up their game and make some real decisions 💪.
 
I don't usually comment but I think it's crazy that governments are so slow to address these issues 🤯. It's not like they're ignoring the problem or anything, but they just seem to be stuck in bureaucratic limbo. The demand for night trains is definitely there, and occupancy rates are through the roof, so what's holding them back? I guess it's true that existing infrastructure and regulatory frameworks can be a major obstacle, but it doesn't have to be insurmountable 🚂. A simple tweak to VAT charges and track access fees could make all the difference, and governments just need to muster up the courage to make some changes 💪. And let's be real, the environmental benefits of night trains far outweigh any perceived costs – it's time for policymakers to take a long-term view 🌎.
 
The EU's net-zero carbon emissions goal has indeed revitalized interest in reviving the European night train network 🚂💨. However, it's disconcerting to see progress stalling due to inadequate funding and regulatory hurdles 🤯. The scrapped Paris-Vienna-Berlin route and derailed Basel-Copenhagen-Malmö plans serve as cautionary tales of how state subsidies can be a major obstacle 🤑.

The uneven playing field created by VAT charges and track access fees is particularly egregious ⚖️. Rail operators are struggling to compete with air travel, which enjoys exemption from these taxes, making it difficult to attract new passengers ✈️. Furthermore, the lack of new rolling stock means trains are being deployed with aging carriages that cannot meet modern safety standards 🚫.

To truly revive the night train network, governments must take bold action 💪. Dropping VAT charges, reducing track access fees, and providing financial backing for struggling operators would go a long way in addressing these challenges 🔓. The EU's commitment to sustainability should be matched by concrete policy changes that support this goal 🌟.

As public support for night trains continues to grow, policymakers must listen and respond with urgency 🗣️. With the right investment and vision, the EU can unlock a more sustainable future for long-distance travel that benefits both passengers and the planet 🌎.
 
I'm really bummed out about this news 🤕. I mean, who doesn't want to hop on a night train and watch the stars whizz by like it's 2000 all over again? Those were the days! Remember when we could actually afford to take trains for longer distances? Now it feels like flying is still king, which is just so... sad 😔. I know they're trying to go green and all that, but come on! It's not like rail travel was always the most eco-friendly option. And what's up with the VAT thing? That's just another reason for us regular folk to feel left out 🤑. I swear, if governments could just get it together and support these initiatives, we'd have a whole network of night trains that'd make our grandparents proud 😊.
 
Back
Top