UK regulators crack down on water executives' bonus loopholes as government steps in to close loopholes allowing top bosses to cash out despite pollution and water shortages.
The UK government is moving to plug a loophole that has allowed senior executives at struggling water firms to receive millions of pounds in bonuses, despite being linked to environmental disasters such as sewage dumping into rivers and seas. Last year's Water (Special Measures) Act banned performance-related bonuses from failing companies, but regulators have struggled to enforce the rule.
Despite the ban, several top executives have received significant pay packages through complex web of parent companies and non-performance related "retention payments". Thames Water chief executive Steve Bullock will still be paid millions in retention payments this year despite being deemed a failing company. Yorkshire Water boss Nicola Shaw netted £1.3m from an offshore company, while South East Water's David Hinton is on track for £400,000 by 2030.
Critics say the loophole has been exploited to evade accountability and punish taxpayers for environmental disasters. Former Undertones frontman Feargal Sharkey said "the water companies were never going to operate within the spirit of the law" and predicted the loopholes would be used to avoid consequences.
New Environment Secretary Emma Reynolds is set to introduce tougher measures, including new rules on disclosure and blocking bonuses paid through parent companies. The move comes as Ofwat, the regulator responsible for enforcing the ban, has already blocked £4m in bonuses this year. Water Minister Emma Hardy said "bonuses should reflect performance" and vowed to end the practice of re-labelling payments to avoid the ban.
MPs have called on regulators to step up their efforts to shut down loopholes, with Liberal Democrat MP Mike Martin saying it was "outrageous" that such loopholes had not already been closed.
The UK government is moving to plug a loophole that has allowed senior executives at struggling water firms to receive millions of pounds in bonuses, despite being linked to environmental disasters such as sewage dumping into rivers and seas. Last year's Water (Special Measures) Act banned performance-related bonuses from failing companies, but regulators have struggled to enforce the rule.
Despite the ban, several top executives have received significant pay packages through complex web of parent companies and non-performance related "retention payments". Thames Water chief executive Steve Bullock will still be paid millions in retention payments this year despite being deemed a failing company. Yorkshire Water boss Nicola Shaw netted £1.3m from an offshore company, while South East Water's David Hinton is on track for £400,000 by 2030.
Critics say the loophole has been exploited to evade accountability and punish taxpayers for environmental disasters. Former Undertones frontman Feargal Sharkey said "the water companies were never going to operate within the spirit of the law" and predicted the loopholes would be used to avoid consequences.
New Environment Secretary Emma Reynolds is set to introduce tougher measures, including new rules on disclosure and blocking bonuses paid through parent companies. The move comes as Ofwat, the regulator responsible for enforcing the ban, has already blocked £4m in bonuses this year. Water Minister Emma Hardy said "bonuses should reflect performance" and vowed to end the practice of re-labelling payments to avoid the ban.
MPs have called on regulators to step up their efforts to shut down loopholes, with Liberal Democrat MP Mike Martin saying it was "outrageous" that such loopholes had not already been closed.
I'm kinda surprised they're cracking down now... like, what took 'em so long? 
Don't get me wrong, it's about time, but £4m in blocked bonuses this year is still a big number... does anyone know how many people that money could've helped instead? 
And what's with the whole "re-labelling payments" thing? It just sounds like a fancy way of avoiding accountability to me... 
. I mean, who wouldn't want to punish water executives for polluting our rivers and wasting precious water during a drought? It's like they think the public is just going to magically forget about all the scandals and messes they've made.
. I'm glad Emma Reynolds is taking a stand, but it's about time. This has been going on for ages and it's disgusting.
And now that Emma Reynolds is taking over as Environment Secretary, I'm hoping she'll actually do something to crack down on this nonsense.
The UK water executives' bonus loopholes are a prime example of how regulatory loopholes can be exploited and used to avoid accountability. It's outrageous that taxpayers have to foot the bill for environmental disasters, while top bosses rake in millions. 
.
. And yet these same people are getting rewarded with millions while taxpayers foot the bill for all the problems they created 
. We need some real change around here 
. And it's about time someone started holding these water executives accountable 
. They're not above the law, no matter how many loopholes they try to use 
.
Nicola Shaw should be ashamed of herself! And what about all those environmental disasters caused by these water companies? Do they really think they can just dump sewage into rivers and seas and then pay themselves millions because of "retention payments"? 
It's like they're trying to get away with something.
. It's like they think they're above the law or something? And now, the government is finally stepping in to shut down their loopholes, about time too 
.
. It's like they're punishing us for having laws in place to protect our environment 
The government needs to crack down on this stuff and make sure these executives are held accountable 
they're more concerned about lining their pockets than the environment they're supposed to be protecting. it's time for them to take responsibility and pay fair wages 
. I mean, who wants to see water executives raking in millions while their companies are struggling and polluting the environment? 
.
.
It's so frustrating to see water executives getting paid millions while the UK is struggling with pollution and water shortages 
. Like, who exactly is holding these people accountable for the harm they're causing? The taxpayers are basically being punished for environmental disasters 
.
.
anyway, now that the gov is crackin down, maybe we'll finally see some real change 
. And last year alone, £4M was blocked by regulators due to these loopholes 
, but £1.3M for Nicola Shaw in 2024? That's 
. The government should be setting stricter rules and holding execs accountable for their actions 
. It's like they think they're above the law or something? And the loopholes are so complex, it's like a game of corporate whack-a-mole 
. It's time for some accountability, you know? And I'm glad the new Environment Secretary is stepping in to introduce some real change 
.
. And as for Feargal Sharkey saying that the water companies were never going to operate within the law... yeah, okay, maybe he's a bit biased since he's been vocal about his disdain for corporate America